Charles vs. McFadden
Who would you rather have ROS Jamaal Charles or Darren McFadden?
  • 1
    John Savariar (480 Reputation Points)
    I'd go with McFadden. His schedule is relatively easy, and the Raiders will feed him the ball any way possible. The problem with Charles is that he's going to be hampered every week by his offense (especially in weeks when Matt Cassel is injured).

    Both guys are Tier 1 RBs, imo. But McFadden might even be a buy-low candidate now, since he hasn't had a huge game yet this season.
  • 0
    Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)
    This is a tough one.. Before Charles regained his confidence and Cassel was still the Qb I would say DMC.. I would take one with better schedule..