Questions
-
1Matt Dirzulaitis (468 Reputation Points)Tough choices. I'd lean towards keeping Dez Bryant and Mike Evans from this group. I believe that Dez is the best of this group and Evans is just 22 with a QB who will only get better.
-
0
-
0Salvador Car (433 Reputation Points)let go of charles for sure
-
0Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)Odell, Charles, and McCoy. WR2s are plentiful this year and running backs are not, and while I like Jordy I don't like him more than the other three
MrFalcon
-
1Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)Charles isn't losing any more snaps than he has in the past, he always excels with limited touches that's how it's always been. He's my guy
-
1Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)I'd rank them Charles > Lacy > Martin > Ingram out of those four. I like the plan to go RB-RB with everyone else going WR (and especially since you already have Beckham Jr.), but as always I'd still take best player available if one of the top guys drop or if those in the 2nd tier (Dez, Jordy, Alshon, Demaryius) seem less risky than the best RB available.
bengardner13 .
-
1Small Paul (484 Reputation Points)Well, basically the only viable options are Landry and Woodhead here. The other players, you are giving up a higher round than what they are currently going at so would not get any value from them. I would probably go with Landry as he would see a ton of targets as per usual and will likely catch a few more TDs than last year. I don't really like keeping QBs since they are so interchangeable.
AJ
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Matt's advice is sound. I'd probably lean toward either Dez or AJ.
-
0Matt Dirzulaitis (468 Reputation Points)I'd probably go with a RB with PPR upside like David Johnson but I would probably also consider AJ Green and Dez Bryant.
Verhaege Family
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)A-Rob and Miller would be my two choices. Marshall is a great option, but assuming you can keep A-Rob for multiple years, his youth gives him an edge. He's a top-five pick in dynasty leagues right now. If you wanted to argue Alshon over Miller, I wouldn't put up a big fight, but Miller is a top-end RB. DT is no joke, either. If you can trade the guys you don't keep and get something back, I'd explore that.
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Miller and Robinson. I am high on Marshall as always but I like the younger Robinson to really emerge this year.
Stephen Rutstein
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Gurley. A top pick in the 7th round?? not even close. you got to keep Gurley
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)All three are stellar options, but I think you have to go with Gurley. He's a cinch top-five pick, and you can get him for a seventh-round choice. Cam and Hopkins are also good deals -- and if you can trade them to someone else who can keep them, pursue that -- but I'd rather have a top 2-3 RB (maybe the top RB) over a QB/WR.
-
0Salvador Car (433 Reputation Points)the moneyline had it going with the falcons, because the money being bet was for the falcons, the house always wins
-
-1Son Nguyen (500 Reputation Points)asdf
edgar colon
-
2Samuel Marshall (377 Reputation Points)Bell and Odell
-
1Robert Lampert (471 Reputation Points)Keep Lev Bell, and Odell Beckham Jr. for sure. Nuk Hopkins is going to have the best quarterback he's ever had throwing him the ball and he'll be playing mad while trying to earn a new contract. Drop the muscle hamster and crybaby Fig Newton to the draft pool. You may be able to pick both of them up for your 2016 roster.
-
0Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)I like Brandon Marshall a lot and I don't like Demaryius with that QB problem at all, but you definitely have to keep those pair of running backs I think. Cooks is good and I like a guy like Keenan Allen or Randall Cobb maybe to go with him, thats a pretty solid start.
You can grab some WRs later that could produce, maybe take a flyer on Josh Gordon if you feel comfortable with the rest of your team comes around.
Good Luck! -
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)I agree with Kacee. Team 3.
-
0Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)As Austan stated, David Johnson and Beckham Jr. are no-brainers--they are the highest rated for this year (and years to come) with almost the lowest cost (13th and 14th round). If you're in full win now mode, then I'd go with Devonta Freeman as he should be great again this year. However, I'm not as excited with his long term outlook as he's got a younger, arguably more talented RB (Tevin Coleman) on his own team and I believe WR's are less volatile than RB's from one year to the next. So, I might roll the dice on Kelvin Benjamin or, if you're really feeling risky, Josh Gordon as if things go right they could be better keepers in the future than Freeman at a lower cost this year.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)OBJ and Johnson are clear must-keeps. I'd probably go Freeman with the other.
Jeremy
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Matt is spot on. Per some ADP data, Evans and Zeke are even top-10 guys.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Matt is spot on. Per some ADP data, Evans and Zeke are even top-10 guys.
wsc79 .
-
1Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)I think I'd go with David Johnson in the 8th. That's much better value than Hopkins in the 3rd--depending on format, I might go David Johnson over Hopkins even if the cost was the same. I'm sure it's tough to lose Bell, but with his history (both injury and suspensions), it's probably time to cut him loose since you have another great option.
-
0bengardner13 . (500 Reputation Points)Johnson in the 8th
Jeremy
-
1Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)I'd go with Marshall and Evans, too. I could probably be talked into McCoy, but Martin and Rawls aren't in the mix, at least for me.
-
1wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Evans and Marshall. RB are a mess this year. Plus if you are dropping McCoy you may be able to pick him up in the third round. Martin is too hit or miss and Rawls may lose the starting job or get stuck in a time share out in Seattle.
Brian Speranzini
-
0Matt Dirzulaitis (468 Reputation Points)I'd rather have Lacy and Moncrief.
-
0
Scott Ballard
-
1
-
1Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Assuming it costs you the same to keep any of those three, I'd go with Watkins.
Daniel Fjelland
-
0Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)Out of those options I'd go with woodhead.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)At that cost, A-Rob, Parker and Edelman aren't much of a value. It's pretty much even with their ADP with the exception of Parker, who is actually going a round later. Woodhead's ADP is in late 7th, so he would give you a nice bargain, especially in .5 PPR.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Lockett and Rawls are two obvious choices. Benji isn't a big value. I'd rather keep Snead, who is going in the 10th.
-
0Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)Agreed. Rawls and Lockett for sure, then Benjamin if you have to keep a third.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Without knowing league specifics and assuming it costs you the same to keep each player, I'd say Brown, Gurley, Johnson and Green in that order. That's four first-round picks. I'd take Bell over Green if he was playing 16 games. Gronk is Gronk, but TE is deep enough you can find decent production later in the draft.
-
1Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)Latavius Murray without a doubt.
-
0Jabez Wesly (500 Reputation Points)Ajayi. Not many backs come back from Achilles tears, so I doubt Arian will be a factor (he had under 3ypc last year as well). Murray will legitimately be pushed by Deandre Washington
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Cam. and its not even close. Gordon is going to have a 4 game suspension. He may get on the field after that, or he may mess up again. Plus he did not look all that great last time around after his 10 game suspension. While he is a spectacular star there is no need to keep him. You can always re draft him. You may end up paying a round or 2 higher but if you keep him you could end up much worse in the QB department.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)I don't love keeping a QB, but Cam is the much better choice between these two. I'd gladly let someone else draft Gordon early. Here is a piece we did on what to expect from Gordon in 2016: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=10&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiMhejpvpPOAhVh9YMKHafTALMQqQIIUzAJ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.numberfire.com%2Fnfl%2Fnews%2F9767%2Fjosh-gordon-is-back-where-should-you-draft-him-in-fantasy-football&usg=AFQjCNGR_rMjPs0S89m7EejMg8DR6gfsdw&sig2=Ju0TErOq3Qhq447EaeQ2rg&bvm=bv.128153897,d.amc
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)If you do keepers by round and Charles is a 1 then no, he is not worth keeping. As a second rounder, maybe but it depends on what else you have on your roster. What you are looking for here is value (if its by round). If its ESPN format where it just the first 2 rounds then you can do much worse than keeping Charles
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)RBs are still the backbone of a good fantasy roster, but there is some data showing that taking a WR early has its merits (https://www.numberfire.com/nfl/news/9541/bust-rates-show-us-that-wide-receivers-are-more-important-than-ever-in-fantasy-football). As for Charles, he's typically going early in the second round in 12-team formats, so he's probably still worth keeping.
edgar colon
-
2Samuel Marshall (377 Reputation Points)Bell and Odell
-
1Robert Lampert (471 Reputation Points)Keep Lev Bell, and Odell Beckham Jr. for sure. Nuk Hopkins is going to have the best quarterback he's ever had throwing him the ball and he'll be playing mad while trying to earn a new contract. Drop the muscle hamster and crybaby Fig Newton to the draft pool. You may be able to pick both of them up for your 2016 roster.
-
0Salvador Car (433 Reputation Points)let go of charles for sure
-
0Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)Odell, Charles, and McCoy. WR2s are plentiful this year and running backs are not, and while I like Jordy I don't like him more than the other three
Daniel Fjelland
-
0Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)Out of those options I'd go with woodhead.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)At that cost, A-Rob, Parker and Edelman aren't much of a value. It's pretty much even with their ADP with the exception of Parker, who is actually going a round later. Woodhead's ADP is in late 7th, so he would give you a nice bargain, especially in .5 PPR.
-
0Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)As Austan stated, David Johnson and Beckham Jr. are no-brainers--they are the highest rated for this year (and years to come) with almost the lowest cost (13th and 14th round). If you're in full win now mode, then I'd go with Devonta Freeman as he should be great again this year. However, I'm not as excited with his long term outlook as he's got a younger, arguably more talented RB (Tevin Coleman) on his own team and I believe WR's are less volatile than RB's from one year to the next. So, I might roll the dice on Kelvin Benjamin or, if you're really feeling risky, Josh Gordon as if things go right they could be better keepers in the future than Freeman at a lower cost this year.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)OBJ and Johnson are clear must-keeps. I'd probably go Freeman with the other.
bengardner13 .
-
1Small Paul (484 Reputation Points)Well, basically the only viable options are Landry and Woodhead here. The other players, you are giving up a higher round than what they are currently going at so would not get any value from them. I would probably go with Landry as he would see a ton of targets as per usual and will likely catch a few more TDs than last year. I don't really like keeping QBs since they are so interchangeable.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Without knowing league specifics and assuming it costs you the same to keep each player, I'd say Brown, Gurley, Johnson and Green in that order. That's four first-round picks. I'd take Bell over Green if he was playing 16 games. Gronk is Gronk, but TE is deep enough you can find decent production later in the draft.
wsc79 .
-
1Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)I think I'd go with David Johnson in the 8th. That's much better value than Hopkins in the 3rd--depending on format, I might go David Johnson over Hopkins even if the cost was the same. I'm sure it's tough to lose Bell, but with his history (both injury and suspensions), it's probably time to cut him loose since you have another great option.
-
0bengardner13 . (500 Reputation Points)Johnson in the 8th
Verhaege Family
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)A-Rob and Miller would be my two choices. Marshall is a great option, but assuming you can keep A-Rob for multiple years, his youth gives him an edge. He's a top-five pick in dynasty leagues right now. If you wanted to argue Alshon over Miller, I wouldn't put up a big fight, but Miller is a top-end RB. DT is no joke, either. If you can trade the guys you don't keep and get something back, I'd explore that.
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Miller and Robinson. I am high on Marshall as always but I like the younger Robinson to really emerge this year.
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Cam. and its not even close. Gordon is going to have a 4 game suspension. He may get on the field after that, or he may mess up again. Plus he did not look all that great last time around after his 10 game suspension. While he is a spectacular star there is no need to keep him. You can always re draft him. You may end up paying a round or 2 higher but if you keep him you could end up much worse in the QB department.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)I don't love keeping a QB, but Cam is the much better choice between these two. I'd gladly let someone else draft Gordon early. Here is a piece we did on what to expect from Gordon in 2016: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=10&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiMhejpvpPOAhVh9YMKHafTALMQqQIIUzAJ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.numberfire.com%2Fnfl%2Fnews%2F9767%2Fjosh-gordon-is-back-where-should-you-draft-him-in-fantasy-football&usg=AFQjCNGR_rMjPs0S89m7EejMg8DR6gfsdw&sig2=Ju0TErOq3Qhq447EaeQ2rg&bvm=bv.128153897,d.amc
Brian Speranzini
-
0Matt Dirzulaitis (468 Reputation Points)I'd rather have Lacy and Moncrief.
-
0
-
0Salvador Car (433 Reputation Points)the moneyline had it going with the falcons, because the money being bet was for the falcons, the house always wins
-
-1Son Nguyen (500 Reputation Points)asdf
-
1Matt Dirzulaitis (468 Reputation Points)Tough choices. I'd lean towards keeping Dez Bryant and Mike Evans from this group. I believe that Dez is the best of this group and Evans is just 22 with a QB who will only get better.
-
0
Scott Ballard
-
1
-
1Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Assuming it costs you the same to keep any of those three, I'd go with Watkins.
-
0Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)I like Brandon Marshall a lot and I don't like Demaryius with that QB problem at all, but you definitely have to keep those pair of running backs I think. Cooks is good and I like a guy like Keenan Allen or Randall Cobb maybe to go with him, thats a pretty solid start.
You can grab some WRs later that could produce, maybe take a flyer on Josh Gordon if you feel comfortable with the rest of your team comes around.
Good Luck! -
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)I agree with Kacee. Team 3.
MrFalcon
-
1Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)Charles isn't losing any more snaps than he has in the past, he always excels with limited touches that's how it's always been. He's my guy
-
1Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)I'd rank them Charles > Lacy > Martin > Ingram out of those four. I like the plan to go RB-RB with everyone else going WR (and especially since you already have Beckham Jr.), but as always I'd still take best player available if one of the top guys drop or if those in the 2nd tier (Dez, Jordy, Alshon, Demaryius) seem less risky than the best RB available.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Lockett and Rawls are two obvious choices. Benji isn't a big value. I'd rather keep Snead, who is going in the 10th.
-
0Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)Agreed. Rawls and Lockett for sure, then Benjamin if you have to keep a third.
Jeremy
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Matt is spot on. Per some ADP data, Evans and Zeke are even top-10 guys.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Matt is spot on. Per some ADP data, Evans and Zeke are even top-10 guys.
AJ
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Matt's advice is sound. I'd probably lean toward either Dez or AJ.
-
0Matt Dirzulaitis (468 Reputation Points)I'd probably go with a RB with PPR upside like David Johnson but I would probably also consider AJ Green and Dez Bryant.
-
1Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)Latavius Murray without a doubt.
-
0Jabez Wesly (500 Reputation Points)Ajayi. Not many backs come back from Achilles tears, so I doubt Arian will be a factor (he had under 3ypc last year as well). Murray will legitimately be pushed by Deandre Washington
Jeremy
-
1Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)I'd go with Marshall and Evans, too. I could probably be talked into McCoy, but Martin and Rawls aren't in the mix, at least for me.
-
1wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Evans and Marshall. RB are a mess this year. Plus if you are dropping McCoy you may be able to pick him up in the third round. Martin is too hit or miss and Rawls may lose the starting job or get stuck in a time share out in Seattle.
Stephen Rutstein
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Gurley. A top pick in the 7th round?? not even close. you got to keep Gurley
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)All three are stellar options, but I think you have to go with Gurley. He's a cinch top-five pick, and you can get him for a seventh-round choice. Cam and Hopkins are also good deals -- and if you can trade them to someone else who can keep them, pursue that -- but I'd rather have a top 2-3 RB (maybe the top RB) over a QB/WR.
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)If you do keepers by round and Charles is a 1 then no, he is not worth keeping. As a second rounder, maybe but it depends on what else you have on your roster. What you are looking for here is value (if its by round). If its ESPN format where it just the first 2 rounds then you can do much worse than keeping Charles
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)RBs are still the backbone of a good fantasy roster, but there is some data showing that taking a WR early has its merits (https://www.numberfire.com/nfl/news/9541/bust-rates-show-us-that-wide-receivers-are-more-important-than-ever-in-fantasy-football). As for Charles, he's typically going early in the second round in 12-team formats, so he's probably still worth keeping.
-
0Salvador Car (433 Reputation Points)the moneyline had it going with the falcons, because the money being bet was for the falcons, the house always wins
-
-1Son Nguyen (500 Reputation Points)asdf
-
1Matt Dirzulaitis (468 Reputation Points)Tough choices. I'd lean towards keeping Dez Bryant and Mike Evans from this group. I believe that Dez is the best of this group and Evans is just 22 with a QB who will only get better.
-
0
edgar colon
-
2Samuel Marshall (377 Reputation Points)Bell and Odell
-
1Robert Lampert (471 Reputation Points)Keep Lev Bell, and Odell Beckham Jr. for sure. Nuk Hopkins is going to have the best quarterback he's ever had throwing him the ball and he'll be playing mad while trying to earn a new contract. Drop the muscle hamster and crybaby Fig Newton to the draft pool. You may be able to pick both of them up for your 2016 roster.
Scott Ballard
-
1
-
1Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Assuming it costs you the same to keep any of those three, I'd go with Watkins.
-
0Salvador Car (433 Reputation Points)let go of charles for sure
-
0Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)Odell, Charles, and McCoy. WR2s are plentiful this year and running backs are not, and while I like Jordy I don't like him more than the other three
-
0Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)I like Brandon Marshall a lot and I don't like Demaryius with that QB problem at all, but you definitely have to keep those pair of running backs I think. Cooks is good and I like a guy like Keenan Allen or Randall Cobb maybe to go with him, thats a pretty solid start.
You can grab some WRs later that could produce, maybe take a flyer on Josh Gordon if you feel comfortable with the rest of your team comes around.
Good Luck! -
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)I agree with Kacee. Team 3.
Daniel Fjelland
-
0Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)Out of those options I'd go with woodhead.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)At that cost, A-Rob, Parker and Edelman aren't much of a value. It's pretty much even with their ADP with the exception of Parker, who is actually going a round later. Woodhead's ADP is in late 7th, so he would give you a nice bargain, especially in .5 PPR.
MrFalcon
-
1Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)Charles isn't losing any more snaps than he has in the past, he always excels with limited touches that's how it's always been. He's my guy
-
1Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)I'd rank them Charles > Lacy > Martin > Ingram out of those four. I like the plan to go RB-RB with everyone else going WR (and especially since you already have Beckham Jr.), but as always I'd still take best player available if one of the top guys drop or if those in the 2nd tier (Dez, Jordy, Alshon, Demaryius) seem less risky than the best RB available.
-
0Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)As Austan stated, David Johnson and Beckham Jr. are no-brainers--they are the highest rated for this year (and years to come) with almost the lowest cost (13th and 14th round). If you're in full win now mode, then I'd go with Devonta Freeman as he should be great again this year. However, I'm not as excited with his long term outlook as he's got a younger, arguably more talented RB (Tevin Coleman) on his own team and I believe WR's are less volatile than RB's from one year to the next. So, I might roll the dice on Kelvin Benjamin or, if you're really feeling risky, Josh Gordon as if things go right they could be better keepers in the future than Freeman at a lower cost this year.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)OBJ and Johnson are clear must-keeps. I'd probably go Freeman with the other.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Lockett and Rawls are two obvious choices. Benji isn't a big value. I'd rather keep Snead, who is going in the 10th.
-
0Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)Agreed. Rawls and Lockett for sure, then Benjamin if you have to keep a third.
bengardner13 .
-
1Small Paul (484 Reputation Points)Well, basically the only viable options are Landry and Woodhead here. The other players, you are giving up a higher round than what they are currently going at so would not get any value from them. I would probably go with Landry as he would see a ton of targets as per usual and will likely catch a few more TDs than last year. I don't really like keeping QBs since they are so interchangeable.
Jeremy
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Matt is spot on. Per some ADP data, Evans and Zeke are even top-10 guys.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Matt is spot on. Per some ADP data, Evans and Zeke are even top-10 guys.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Without knowing league specifics and assuming it costs you the same to keep each player, I'd say Brown, Gurley, Johnson and Green in that order. That's four first-round picks. I'd take Bell over Green if he was playing 16 games. Gronk is Gronk, but TE is deep enough you can find decent production later in the draft.
AJ
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)Matt's advice is sound. I'd probably lean toward either Dez or AJ.
-
0Matt Dirzulaitis (468 Reputation Points)I'd probably go with a RB with PPR upside like David Johnson but I would probably also consider AJ Green and Dez Bryant.
wsc79 .
-
1Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)I think I'd go with David Johnson in the 8th. That's much better value than Hopkins in the 3rd--depending on format, I might go David Johnson over Hopkins even if the cost was the same. I'm sure it's tough to lose Bell, but with his history (both injury and suspensions), it's probably time to cut him loose since you have another great option.
-
0bengardner13 . (500 Reputation Points)Johnson in the 8th
-
1Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)Latavius Murray without a doubt.
-
0Jabez Wesly (500 Reputation Points)Ajayi. Not many backs come back from Achilles tears, so I doubt Arian will be a factor (he had under 3ypc last year as well). Murray will legitimately be pushed by Deandre Washington
Verhaege Family
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)A-Rob and Miller would be my two choices. Marshall is a great option, but assuming you can keep A-Rob for multiple years, his youth gives him an edge. He's a top-five pick in dynasty leagues right now. If you wanted to argue Alshon over Miller, I wouldn't put up a big fight, but Miller is a top-end RB. DT is no joke, either. If you can trade the guys you don't keep and get something back, I'd explore that.
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Miller and Robinson. I am high on Marshall as always but I like the younger Robinson to really emerge this year.
Jeremy
-
1Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)I'd go with Marshall and Evans, too. I could probably be talked into McCoy, but Martin and Rawls aren't in the mix, at least for me.
-
1wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Evans and Marshall. RB are a mess this year. Plus if you are dropping McCoy you may be able to pick him up in the third round. Martin is too hit or miss and Rawls may lose the starting job or get stuck in a time share out in Seattle.
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Cam. and its not even close. Gordon is going to have a 4 game suspension. He may get on the field after that, or he may mess up again. Plus he did not look all that great last time around after his 10 game suspension. While he is a spectacular star there is no need to keep him. You can always re draft him. You may end up paying a round or 2 higher but if you keep him you could end up much worse in the QB department.
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)I don't love keeping a QB, but Cam is the much better choice between these two. I'd gladly let someone else draft Gordon early. Here is a piece we did on what to expect from Gordon in 2016: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=10&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiMhejpvpPOAhVh9YMKHafTALMQqQIIUzAJ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.numberfire.com%2Fnfl%2Fnews%2F9767%2Fjosh-gordon-is-back-where-should-you-draft-him-in-fantasy-football&usg=AFQjCNGR_rMjPs0S89m7EejMg8DR6gfsdw&sig2=Ju0TErOq3Qhq447EaeQ2rg&bvm=bv.128153897,d.amc
Stephen Rutstein
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)Gurley. A top pick in the 7th round?? not even close. you got to keep Gurley
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)All three are stellar options, but I think you have to go with Gurley. He's a cinch top-five pick, and you can get him for a seventh-round choice. Cam and Hopkins are also good deals -- and if you can trade them to someone else who can keep them, pursue that -- but I'd rather have a top 2-3 RB (maybe the top RB) over a QB/WR.
Brian Speranzini
-
0Matt Dirzulaitis (468 Reputation Points)I'd rather have Lacy and Moncrief.
-
0
-
0wsc79 . (413 Reputation Points)If you do keepers by round and Charles is a 1 then no, he is not worth keeping. As a second rounder, maybe but it depends on what else you have on your roster. What you are looking for here is value (if its by round). If its ESPN format where it just the first 2 rounds then you can do much worse than keeping Charles
-
0Austan Kas (538 Reputation Points)RBs are still the backbone of a good fantasy roster, but there is some data showing that taking a WR early has its merits (https://www.numberfire.com/nfl/news/9541/bust-rates-show-us-that-wide-receivers-are-more-important-than-ever-in-fantasy-football). As for Charles, he's typically going early in the second round in 12-team formats, so he's probably still worth keeping.
Sorry, there are no more questions for this feed.