What do you guys think about this trade?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Clarence Lam

Trade away Eli and Willis McGahee for Pierre Thomas and Peyton Manning?
Here's my team: http://www.numberfire.com/nfl/user-teams/9519

0

al staton (500 Reputation Points)
With Sproles injured I'd go for it, otherwise, not quite sure.
0

dong le (461 Reputation Points)
Yes, good trade, peyton scores a solid 20-25 points weekly
0

Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)
I like it.. Eli has a tougher schedule than Peyton and he has lost out of td's to the giants running game lately.. THomas is next in line to Sproles in passing game and he already gets more of the carries, so I'm okay with it.
0

Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)
For me, the Mannings are about even (though Peyton has been better lately) while McGahee is way better than Pierre Thomas, so I don't like this trade.