Should I trade Percy Harvin & Michael Turner for McFadden & Roddy White?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Sukhesh Miryala

Should I trade Percy Harvin & Michael Turner for McFadden & Roddy White?

I have MJD, Bradshaw, Leshoure as my other RBs & Larry Fitz, Colston, Desean Jackson, and Greg Jennings as my other WRs. Its a 10 person non PPR standard scoring league.

0

Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)
I would see if you can trade Turner/DMc straight up.. I like Percy over Roddy and would keep Percy..
2 Comments

↳

Sukhesh Miryala (500 Reputation Points)
I get the upgrade on RB bc of the downgrade on the WR. I'm trying to figure out whether DMC can make up for diff b/t Roddy and Percy.

↳

Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)
That is hard to know.. I know that he has the schedule to do it, but if he can is a different story. ON most week though Roddy shouldn't be outscored by Percy by that much.
0

Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)
I like this trade as Percy and Roddy are basically even and McFadden is a huge upgrade over Turner. Go for it!
0

MCubed18 (500 Reputation Points)
I wouldnt. Percy has been a beast this year, consistently putting up numbers. Roddy and Mcfadden have been inconsistent all year
1 Comment

↳

Sukhesh Miryala (500 Reputation Points)
Yeah, but I feel like McFadden turned the corner and has gotten a ton of carries, no? I agree Harvin is more consistent but Roddy can have big games too. I feel like I need to take a gamble because MJD is out.