Questions
ELI or RG3?
I am stumped. I've gone over the numbers and matchups but I can't seem to pick. Plus I'm biased and like the Giants so all I see is RG3 having a mediocre game and Eli going off
  • 1
    Timothy Hohwald (500 Reputation Points)
    I would go with Eli. I have a hard time trusting rookies on the road. In the big picture though, I would look to trde on these two. You could get a top 5 player at any position that you could start every week. Leaving you without the stress of pondering this question, week in & week out.
  • 1
    John McDaniel (434 Reputation Points)
    Tough call! My gut says Eli at home with all his weapons playing is the better start.
  • 0
    dong le (461 Reputation Points)
    Rg3, eli has a tough time against wash def as apparent last year when he was swept by them. That being said if eli is down, he might be desperate and throw for 500 yrds. Safe bet tho is rg3.
  • 0
    Andy Cochrane (110 Reputation Points)
    Eli slightly ahead of RG 3. Hardly anything in it though. The only thing that puts him ahead is being at home.
    1 Comment
    Dylan Maehrlein (480 Reputation Points)
    I've started Eli all year and only lost once. I'm in the same ballpark as you. I just worry about him being a better road QB. Thanks though
  • 0
    Sam Osika (500 Reputation Points)
    RG3. Although Eli is good, RG3 adds a different dimension with his legs.
Question Tags
Eli Manning No Recent News
Robert Griffin III No Recent News
Question Tags
Eli Manning No Recent News
Robert Griffin III No Recent News