Which WR should I grab?
I just lost Ryan Williams for the season. Want to know which one of these WR's you think is best to waiver

Heyward-Bay, Titus Young, Brian Hartline, Andre Roberts, Andrew Hawkins, Mario Manningham, or Nate Burleson
  • 1
    Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)
    Hartline is the only one of those options that is the #1 WR option on their team. Sure, the Dolphins offense might not be that great, but the upside of a #1 WR on a bad team is still often better than the 2nd or 3rd option on a good team (as with Hartline two weeks ago). As for the rest, I would rate them Hawkins > Burleson > Roberts > Manningham.
    Zach Pinner (555 Reputation Points)
    forgot to add Heyward and Titus to the WR prospects. neither the #1, but figured I'd throw them in
    Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)
    I think both of those would be down there near Manningham, though Titus Young does have some upside or as a handcuff for Calvin Johnson.
  • 0
    Thomas Naughton (458 Reputation Points)
    I'm staying away from all things Raiders, so DHB is out. Also, Burleson and Young are fighting for targets in Detroit's offence, and until one pulls away, I don't like either (Did I mention they have the target monster of Calvin Johnson ahead of them on the depth chart), and they are #3 and #4 on the passing priority chain. Manningham will have a nice game or two, but he's simply not consistent enough to start. And Arizona's offence got absolutely pulverized by the Rams (underrated secondary), but the Cardinal's offense just looked horrible all around on Thursday, so I'm shying away from Roberts. And that leaves... Hartline. He's been receiving a disgusting number of targets (52) and is the #1 WR in Miami, and therefore should keep getting somewhat consistent numbers (He does still have a rookie throwing him the ball)