is this a fair trade?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Jay Titterington

Matt Ryan, Jerrick McKinnon, Vincent Jackson for Andrew Luck and Kelvin Benjamin, Darren McFadden? Is it fair? which side would you rather have?

0

Dirk Dirkowitz (411 Reputation Points)
I think it's reasonably fair. I like Ryan a small amount better than Luck, Benjamin has a little more upside than Jackson but they're fairly even, and McKinnon has hugely more upside than McFadden but McFadden has the starting job right now. I think I'd lean a little bit more towards the Ryan side unless I was immediately hurting at RB.
0

Sean Lee (397 Reputation Points)
I would much rather have the Andrew Luck side