Who to start, Bernard Pierce or Knile Davis?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Nicolas Fenu

Who to start, Bernard Pierce or Knile Davis?

I know there are a lot of "if's" in this situation, between wondering how many carries Pierce will see as opposed to Forsett, and wondering if Jamaal Charles will play. Even if Charles does play and sort of splits carries with Davis as a limitation of his injury, is Davis still worth a start? All things considered I'm not sure who to go with here, please help! thank you

0

p j (384 Reputation Points)
If Charles doesn't suit up then I'd start Davis in a heartbeat. If he does, then I'd have to give serious consideration to starting Pierce, even thought he's slightly banged up.
1 Comment

↳

Psycho (399 Reputation Points)
only problem i see with that is...pierce plays at 1pm on sunday..knile davis not until 4:30pm on sunday..that means unless you know for SURE that charles isnt playing you are rolling the dice..i'd rather KNOW that p[ierce IS playing then davis MIGHT play IMO
0

Psycho (399 Reputation Points)
i thought the same thing when i got davis off the WW i was thrilled..then charles starts practicing...so i would say start Pierce...even though forsett cuts into pierce's runs...pierce will get more carries. with davis its a crap-shoot..you wanna take a chance..or get a sure thing? your choice..i'm taking the sure thing
1 Comment

↳

Nicolas Fenu (402 Reputation Points)
yea I'm going to go with you on this one, while I'm definitely worried about what kind of numbers Pierce will put up we know he's going to split and get the majority of the carries. With Davis if Jamaal suits up he'll obviously overshadow Davis and I don't like banking on questionable injured players not suiting up.