Drop Gerhart for Pierce, Bradshaw, Rainey, or Davis?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Shawn Yarnell

Drop Gerhart for Pierce, Bradshaw, Rainey, or Davis?

My Team, Standard league:

Luck, Foles, Forte, Doug Martin, Gerhart, Sproles, Hyde, Cobb, Percy Harvin, Reggie Wayne, TY Hilton, Mike Wallace with streamer TE and D.

My RBs, despite a seeming solid group, have been a complete letdown so far. Sproles, who has rode the bench, is by far the best scorer.

I am considering dropping Gerhart for Ahmad Bradshaw, Bernard Pierce, or Kniles Davis.

Bradshawn shares with Richardson, but Trent blows, so Bradshaw should take over even more carries imo. Pierce is the starter, but Harbough says he is "going with the hot hand", meaning inconsistent. Rainey is going to play in place of Martin, who is on my team, and had a big day this weekend. Davis is a temp guy until Charles returns as well as injury prone himself.

Are any of these guys worth dropping Gerhart over? He plays for Jacksonville for goodness sake. They ran less plays this weekend than Philly did in a few halves last year.

1

Jen Ryan (563 Reputation Points)
I wouldn't drop Gerhart, bortles has to start eventually and he is the RB1 there - Trent does blow, i thought he was going to cry last night - i know Knile is the hot pick up right now, but I'm really high on Bradshaw
1 Comment

↳

Dirk Dirkowitz (411 Reputation Points)
Agreed.
1

Sam Hauss (371 Reputation Points)
If you need a starter this week I would probably drop him for Knile Davis. Otherwise I would hold tight and hope things improve over the next few weeks.
0

Chris Wall (289 Reputation Points)
One more thing I wanted to add, if you are playing the Charles owner this week, I would make it key to get kniles Davis so he can't. By taking kniles from him u will leave him stuck replacing his rb1 this week and should help ur win this week greatly, if ur playing the charles owner that is. I'm a Charles owner and have that fear, so it could help u.