Keeper Advice

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Brandon Arnold

Keeper Advice

This is for a 12 team keeper league (Down from 16), no PPR. I need to keep four and I will get to pick starting in the 5th Round. Who should I keep:
Lesean McCoy
DeMarco Murray
Montee Ball
Arian Foster
Cam Newton
Victor Cruz
Randall Cobb

1

Justin Roland (308 Reputation Points)
Wow, this is actually pretty tough. Without a doubt, McCoy. I will argue the rest and let you decide
Murray - If he stays healthy he is probably a fringe top 12 back for the next few years. Value down a bit with no PPR
Montee Ball - In THIS Denver offense, he could go nuts. Exit Peyton Manning and he drops off from top 12 status
Arian Foster - if he has healthy years left, he is a no brainer. That is tough to predict though
Cam Newton - Im not sure what the QB situation is in a 12 team keeper, but i would want to keep Newton if the position is scarce. Never has finished less than 4th on fantasy scoring in his young career
Cruz - No argument
Cobb - Its close but no, you cant keep Cobb

I would take 3 of the top RB's and Cam. McCoy and Murray for sure IMO, and choose between Ball and Foster.
0

Zach Brunner (399 Reputation Points)
McCoy. Murray. Ball. Cobb. If you don't like Cobb, pick Cruz. Both will have big years performing in the same exact role for their respected teams.
0

Ted Van Green (384 Reputation Points)
mccoy no brainer along with ball because i think he is going to be really good this year. See what available qbs look like. If a guy like romo or ryan is not kept i would throw newton back in the ring. Its a tossup for me between foster and murray i cant pick(gun to my head:murray) then cobb. Gives you three top 12 backs and sets you at that position and gives you a decent wr1 for a 12 team league.