Log in to numberFire

To get the full benefits of numberFire, please log in.

You'll get the best projections in the business!

Don't have an account? Click here to sign up!

Start Winning In Seconds

To get the full benefits of numberFire, please sign up.

You'll get the best projections in the business!

By registering, you indicate that you agree to the Terms Of Service.

Already have an account? Click here to log in!
Questions
Ask Question +
James JR
Should I trade Karlos Williams and Matt Forte for Brandon Marshall and Chris Johnson
12 team league with .5ppr, Starting lineup of QB/RB/RB/WR/WR/TE/Flex/DEF/K

This is how my team looks
QB- Russell Wilson, Eli Manning
RB- Matt Forte, Frank Gore, Arian Foster, Karlos Williams
WR- Odell Beckham Jr., Michael Crabtree, Vincent Jackson, Allen Robinson, Devin Funchess, Leonard Hankerson
TE-Charles Clay, Kyle Rudolph
DEF- Texans
K- Steven Hauschka

I'm really torn on this trade. I figure that Forte and Marshall cancel each other out but I'm not so sure about Karlos and CJ being even. Keep in mind that I'm 0-3, playing the guy who's offering me the trade this week and he also has Lesean McCoy. His only other running backs are Andre Ellington and Bishop Sankey. I'm worried that if I make this trade I'll basically be beating myself this week. Any help is appreciated
  • 0
    Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)
    Its essentially Forte for Marshall, so Forte is the better end of the deal. You might could do a Karlos Williams/Allen Robinson for a get a better WR2.
  • 0
    Daniel Halford (605 Reputation Points)
    There is no way I would be making this trade. There is a reason you took Matt Forte first round rather than a top receiver because he is much harder to find a replacement for. You could do with a better WR2 looking at your team and Marshall has started well but I think you should get more for Forte. As for Johnson and Karlos its a coin flip, both could be great or both could fall away sharply. There is only one of them that has stung me in fantasy in the past though!!
    1 Comment
    ↳
    -VSOP- (359 Reputation Points)
    agree with Daniel...all 4 times. Do not make this trade.
  • 0
    Daniel Halford (605 Reputation Points)
    There is no way I would be making this trade. There is a reason you took Matt Forte first round rather than a top receiver because he is much harder to find a replacement for. You could do with a better WR2 looking at your team and Marshall has started well but I think you should get more for Forte. As for Johnson and Karlos its a coin flip, both could be great or both could fall away sharply. There is only one of them that has stung me in fantasy in the past though!!
  • 0
    Daniel Halford (605 Reputation Points)
    There is no way I would be making this trade. There is a reason you took Matt Forte first round rather than a top receiver because he is much harder to find a replacement for. You could do with a better WR2 looking at your team and Marshall has started well but I think you should get more for Forte. As for Johnson and Karlos its a coin flip, both could be great or both could fall away sharply. There is only one of them that has stung me in fantasy in the past though!!
  • 0
    Daniel Halford (605 Reputation Points)
    There is no way I would be making this trade. There is a reason you took Matt Forte first round rather than a top receiver because he is much harder to find a replacement for. You could do with a better WR2 looking at your team and Marshall has started well but I think you should get more for Forte. As for Johnson and Karlos its a coin flip, both could be great or both could fall away sharply. There is only one of them that has stung me in fantasy in the past though!!
Question Tags
Brandon Marshall No Recent News
Chris Johnson No Recent News
Matt Forte No Recent News
Karlos Williams No Recent News
NFL
Related Questions
Question Tags
Brandon Marshall No Recent News
Chris Johnson No Recent News
Matt Forte No Recent News
Karlos Williams No Recent News
NFL