Questions
Gregg Gregg
Keeper Question
10 team keeper, 4 keepers per team. Already keeping Forte in the 2nd, Geo Bernard in the 7th and Gordon in the 11th:Marshall in the 1st
Cobb in the 3rd
Harvin in the 6th
Ellington in the 6th
Harvin was a legit #1 receiver two years back - kind of leaning him given his price of a 6th, Cobb I think isn't really a value pick for the 3rd round, but is solid. Least amount of risk is Marshall but I would be giving up my first round pick for him so I don't think ill do it.
-
1Eamonn Choukrane (665 Reputation Points)i'm not crazy about any of that value but i think that I would go cobb
-
1Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)I agree, Marshall for a first round pick is too much (especially if your pick isn't at the end of the first round). I don't think Cobb is three rounds better than Harvin, so I'd go with Percy if you only get to do one or the other (but since you have 4 keepers, it sounds like you get them both). I'd say if you let Marshall go and grab the best available in the first round (I'd probably go RB), Marshall (or someone comparable) should still be there for you in the second.5 Comments↳Gregg Gregg (276 Reputation Points)oh sorry, forgot to put in there i was also keeping Geo Bernard in the 7th, so really i can only pick one. But yeah I think im leaning more Harvin now since Tate is gone.↳Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)Yes, Bernard in the 7th is a no brainer. Some may argue for Cobb, but Harvin has as much upside or more (though there's obviously a lot of risk), but I think I'd roll the dice and keep my 3rd round pick.↳reignman (446 Reputation Points)definitely keep bernard.↳Gregg Gregg (276 Reputation Points)any of this change if I could keep ellington in the 6th as well? Mendenhall just retired.↳Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)Depends on your league settings, but assuming you can play 2 RB's and a flex (since you would be keeping 3 RB's), I think I would go for Ellington over Harvin and Cobb.
-
1Keith Goldner (815 Reputation Points)Yeah giving up a 1st for Marshall is too much, though the Cobb and Harvin values aren't very good either. But I'd probably go Cobb, Harvin then Marshall
Brandon Marshall 
Percy Harvin 
Randall Cobb