Questions
Nathan L
Trade McFadden and Gates for Rice?
McFadden's got a great schedule, but isn't really getting the blocking to have a Top-5 season. Gates has been in a slump this year, and I have Heath Miller, who I am beginning to trust more than Gates. Is it worth trading McFadden/Gates for Rice?
-
0Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)No harm in trying it! if doesn't work at first maybe he will send counter offer.5 Comments↳Nathan L (537 Reputation Points)Yeah, he ended up not going for it, but countered with Morris + Gates or Morris + Cobb for Rice. Would you do either of those? Morris has been very solid all season and isn't showing signs of stopping, so while Rice is obviously better, the question is, how much better? Thoughts?↳Nathan L (537 Reputation Points)Yeah, he ended up not going for it, but countered with Morris + Gates or Morris + Cobb for Rice. Would you do either of those? Morris has been very solid all season and isn't showing signs of stopping, so while Rice is obviously better, the question is, how much better? Thoughts?↳Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)I would probably give him Morris/Cobb if you can afford it. the thing is your trading for a top back. You need to at least give one back in return.. I like Rice a little more since he is more likely to get a td each week.↳Nathan L (537 Reputation Points)Thanks. My other two WRs are Harvin/Julio Jones, so I'm not starting Cobb. But if I give up Cobb my next WR is Hartline, so it leaves me without a good backup. You wouldn't do Morris + Gates for Rice? I seem to be leaning a bit more towards that, but would be curious if you think that's too much to give up. . .↳Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)I think Gates is starting to pick up his play. Him and Rivers are connecting more. I wouldn't want to give that up.
-
0John (542 Reputation Points)If the other person agrees than yes. But this is almost veto worthy lopsided, I don't how you can make the case for the other side.
-
0dong le (461 Reputation Points)Trade it
-
0Matthews (542 Reputation Points)rice is awesome thats who id want3 Comments↳Nathan L (537 Reputation Points)Would you do it if he insisted on Heath Miller instead? Or if he wanted Randall Cobb (leaving me thin at WR - only have Harvin, Julio Jones, and Hartline)?↳John (542 Reputation Points)I'd say no on Heath Miller, yes on Cobb. Unless you have a TE better than Miller.↳John (542 Reputation Points)I guess that was a dumb question since Miler is the 2-3 TE right now
-
0James Macisso (500 Reputation Points)YES YES YES
-
0Zachary Shane Donaldson (386 Reputation Points)YES!
-
0Jacob S. (265 Reputation Points)Yes. Absolutely. If you can pull this off I think it'd be great.
Antonio Gates 
Darren McFadden 
Ray Rice