Log in to numberFire

To get the full benefits of numberFire, please log in.

You'll get the best projections in the business!

Don't have an account? Click here to sign up!

Start Winning In Seconds

To get the full benefits of numberFire, please sign up.

You'll get the best projections in the business!

By registering, you indicate that you agree to the Terms Of Service.

Already have an account? Click here to log in!
Questions
Ask Question +
George Possley
Trade: Andre Johnson and Ryan Matthews for Torey Smith and Doug Martin. Who won?
I approved this trade for a team that I had taken over for an owner who quit competing. There is now a new owner. He got Smith/Martin. Did I screw him?
  • 0
    Matthews (542 Reputation Points)
    i disagree with the majority here, i like the martin side better...mathews is made of glass just like last night with the ankle plus brown and battle get touches left and right. Andre has been a frustration all yr. At least martin is a lead back with blount not being very scary at all..torrey is boom or bust, but with bal defense being so banged up, they might have to throw it a lot more now.
  • 0
    Matthews (542 Reputation Points)
    i disagree with the majority here, i like the martin side better...mathews is made of glass just like last night with the ankle plus brown and battle get touches left and right. Andre has been a frustration all yr. At least martin is a lead back with blount not being very scary at all..torrey is boom or bust, but with bal defense being so banged up, they might have to throw it a lot more now.
  • 0
    John Savariar (480 Reputation Points)
    Whoever gets Mathews/Johnson is getting a better deal. I would rate Andre higher than Torrey Smith since Smith has only had one good week.

    For Martin v. Mathews, the situation is a little more complicated. The Bucs just lost Carl Nicks for the year, and Martin has had the most success running behind him. With that in mind, I'd rather own Mathews for the rest of the year.
  • 0
    Billy Vigliotti (500 Reputation Points)
    You didn't screw them at all. I am not sure I would personally make that deal for my team, but this deal is deeper than the names on the surface. Andre/Matthews appears sexier bc of name value. But (depending on format) they are averaging about 7.5pts and 9pts respectively. Whereas Smith and Martin are averaging 9.25 and 13pts respectively. Martin's average is a bit inflated bc a blow up vs Min and Smith bc a blow up vs NE, but even if you remove those games the averages still benefit the Smith/Martin side slightly. It is not a bad deal at all.
    1 Comment
    ↳
    George Possley (531 Reputation Points)
    Thanks, Billy. Those are the numbers I looked at when evaluating. This site's projections going forward are helpful too.
  • 0
    Jameson Wooten (500 Reputation Points)
    I honestly think Andre is much much better than Torrey, and Martin has just a little more value than Mathews. Whoever got Johnson and Mathews won in my opinion.
Question Tags
Andre Johnson No Recent News
Ryan Mathews No Recent News
Torrey Smith No Recent News
Doug Martin No Recent News
NFL
Related Questions
Question Tags
Andre Johnson No Recent News
Ryan Mathews No Recent News
Torrey Smith No Recent News
Doug Martin No Recent News
NFL