Log in to numberFire

To get the full benefits of numberFire, please log in.

You'll get the best projections in the business!

Don't have an account? Click here to sign up!

Start Winning In Seconds

To get the full benefits of numberFire, please sign up.

You'll get the best projections in the business!

By registering, you indicate that you agree to the Terms Of Service.

Already have an account? Click here to log in!
Questions
Ask Question +
Stephen Yeager
Would you trade Aaron Rodgers and Reggie Bush for Eli Manning and Jamaal Charles?
Feel like I have to upgrade at RB and I think that Eli is somewhat underrated and will only pick it up as it gets closer to the end of the season.
  • 2
    John (542 Reputation Points)
    I would wait another week to reevaulute Charles. That last game with him only getting 5 attempts, and him only scoring 5.7 points in the last two games is scary. If he can repeat what he did to SD in week 4, it may be worth a second look. Part of me thinks that Charles owners should have sold high after week 5.
    2 Comments
    ↳
    Michael Geller (500 Reputation Points)
    Great answer, John!
    ↳
    John (542 Reputation Points)
    Better yet you just have to wait 7 hours...forgot they are playing tonight
  • 1
    Brandon Harris (544 Reputation Points)
    Eli isn't even close to being on the level of Aaron Rodgers. You would be significantly downgrading at QB for a running back that has just as many questions as the one you're giving up. I do believe Charles is an upgrade over Bush but everyone is freaking out that Daniel Thomas got more carries than Bush. Most of those carries though came with the Dolphins dominating and the game out of hand. Thomas does steal goal line carries but I believe you lose if you do this trade.
  • 1
    Michael Geller (500 Reputation Points)
    As far as the RBs, I'm very worried about Reggie Bush. Daniel Thomas is healthy and is starting to creep in on his carries, particularly around the goal line. Their QB is banged up and their offense wasn't that great to start with, which is worrisome. However it's not like Jamaal Charles is a sure-fire bet either; their offense is even worse! However JC is probably the only legitimate threat on that team, so you have to think they'll have to start feeding him the rock more.

    As far as Eli vs. Aaron, I do agree that Eli isn't playing where he should be. The good news is that he's got a soft schedule coming up, including great matchups against in-division defensive weakling Washington and the Saints. I think I might do this, but I'd try to get someone a little better than Charles if possible.
  • 0
    Jerry Lillig (500 Reputation Points)
    No......I would NOT give up Rodgers for Manning
  • 0
    Adam Savrin (349 Reputation Points)
    No way. Eli is elite in real life. He's not elite in fantasy. Charles and Bush are both up and down. Charles does have a crazy good playoff schedule. But giving up Rodgers is too much.

    The deal would be fair if it was Charles/Eli for Bush and Peyton Manning
  • 0
    Jacob S. (265 Reputation Points)
    I'd stick with what you have. You don't really gain anything by making this trade. Both Charles and Bush are kind of up in the air right now.
  • 0
    Matthews (542 Reputation Points)
    its not terrible, especially with charles having upside even though they dont use him like they should...i would still stick with the rodgers side
  • 0
    Billy Vigliotti (500 Reputation Points)
    I would not.
Question Tags
Aaron Rodgers No Recent News
Eli Manning No Recent News
Jamaal Charles No Recent News
Reggie Bush No Recent News
NFL
Related Questions
Question Tags
Aaron Rodgers No Recent News
Eli Manning No Recent News
Jamaal Charles No Recent News
Reggie Bush No Recent News
NFL