Trade proposal: cam newton & magahee for Big Ben and shonn Greene (team getting Big Ben has ponder) team getting cam has Matty ice.
  • 1
    Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)
    I like the Roethlisburger side of the trade much better as they're actually getting a starting QB while the other side is just switching backup QB's. As for Shonn Greene and McGahee, I would rank them almost equal so that is a wash for me.
  • 0
    Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)
    I like Ben over Cam, but would McGahee over Greene!!
  • 0
    The Diesel (386 Reputation Points)
    No way in hell is mcgahee = to greene. McGahee> greene and > by a huge margin
  • 0
    Tom Olp (500 Reputation Points)
    I would rank McGahee above Greene by a decent amount, because I think that the Broncos have plenty of passing which has been opening up more running lanes for McGahee, while the Jets offense is just a complete mess. Also, McGahee has been more involved in the passing game as well. Plus, I think Newton has some upside still, and depending on match-ups I'd rank him ahead of Ryan because of his ability to get yards on the ground. So I'd definitely do it if I was getting Newton and McGahee.