Questions
What do you think of this trade?
Give up Peyton Manning and Mikel Leshoure for Cam Newton and Jamaal Charles? This is a standard league.
  • 0
    Paul C (500 Reputation Points)
    Charles is a great upgrade, but for how long? I'd question his durability considering his injury last year...although he's getting a good workload, I'd worry about the 2nd half of the season and whether Hillis (when healthy) will cut into that workload. Who else you have on your roster would be key, but just based on all things being equal, keep Peyton...I'd gamble more on his durability and consistent production than Charles (especially since KC's offense is one-dimensional).
    2 Comments
    Deepiceman (266 Reputation Points)
    This is a trade "accepted" and in "voting" period in my league and I wanted to see what the consesus is on a trade like this. Team giving up Peyton has Dalton as backup (on bye this week) and getting Jamaal will solidify the RB position since MJD went down over the weekend. Cam's backup is Alex Smith, so Peyton will bring consistency and RB option will become a little thin. Gore would be the stud now. I think its better deal for the team getting Peyton although number wise its about the same.
    Paul C (500 Reputation Points)
    Sounds like a win for both teams to some degree. Without all the details, I'd still say the team getting Charles fairs better...for now.
  • 0
    Andy Cochrane (110 Reputation Points)
    Who are your other RB?
  • 0
    Buddy Matyjas (725 Reputation Points)
    Who is your backup QB
Question Tags
Cam Newton No Recent News
Jamaal Charles No Recent News
Mikel Leshoure No Recent News
Peyton Manning No Recent News
Question Tags
Cam Newton No Recent News
Jamaal Charles No Recent News
Mikel Leshoure No Recent News
Peyton Manning No Recent News