Questions
Blockbuster trade advice needed
Oh, this one is HUGE deal. I'm debating trading RG3, Reggie Wayne, Reggie Bush, and Brent Celek for Eli Manning, Demaryius Thomas, and Marshawn Lynch. 0.5 PPR.
  • 1
    Ankit Monga (424 Reputation Points)
    no way cause rg3 is way better than eli fantasy wise, wayne is doing better than thomas right now, and lynch is a little bit better than bush but you would be losing more than winning.
    1 Comment
    BEAST MODE (607 Reputation Points)
    agree do not do trade. I have Eli as my starter but I would take RGIII all day. Wayne and Thomas are a wash. Slight advantage for Lynch over Reggie b, but Reggie has speed and can explode more often than Lynch. Stay the course.
  • 0
    dong le (461 Reputation Points)
    Why would you do that? Your players are better
  • 0
    Eli Bogursky (301 Reputation Points)
    I wouldn't do this. You're downgrading a lot at QB, and not making that much of a gain at WR and none at RB, especially since Bush just had his bye and Lynch hasn't had his yet. Also, Lynch has a far tougher remaining schedule, playing MIN, MIA, CHI, SF, which gives him a tough matchup in 1/2 of the remaining weeks. Bush has a ton of good matchups, playing NYJ, IND, TEN, BUF, JAX, BUF again. He has a good matchup in 2/3 of the remaining weeks. I just don't see you gaining anything at RB, and the gain at WR is small given how much Wayne gets targeted. The difference between RG3 and Eli is large, and you give up Celek also.
  • 0
    Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)
    I have both RG3 and Eli, so I know you will be losing a lot at QB.. especially with the way Giants have been able to run.. Less action for Eli..Keep Rg3. I think Lynch is a great pick-up and would still try to get him.. I think Thomas and Lynch are close to a wash.. I would keep or get the one with better schedule going forward.
  • 0
    The Diesel (386 Reputation Points)
    No way should you do this. Left side > right side
  • 0
    Andy Cochrane (110 Reputation Points)
    I would debate whether to do this TBH. Eli is more durable than RG 3 but is he that much better? Thomas over Wayne? Bush in a PPR is pretty good too.
Question Tags
Brent Celek No Recent News
Demaryius Thomas No Recent News
Eli Manning No Recent News
Marshawn Lynch No Recent News
Reggie Bush No Recent News
Reggie Wayne No Recent News
Robert Griffin III No Recent News
Question Tags
Brent Celek No Recent News
Demaryius Thomas No Recent News
Eli Manning No Recent News
Marshawn Lynch No Recent News
Reggie Bush No Recent News
Reggie Wayne No Recent News
Robert Griffin III No Recent News