Good trade?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Mike P

Good trade?

Sitting at 4-2 and thinking of trading Colston and Leshoure for Victor Cruz...I also have McCoy, Charles, Sproles, Vick Ballard, and Pierre Thomas at RB & Fitzgerald, Brown, Britt at WR....thoughts?

0

George Possley (531 Reputation Points)
I"m going to say DO this deal. Colston, in my experience, always gets hurt and tends to disappear from time to time. Cruz has shown the ability to stay healthy and Eli looks for him. Losing Leshoure isn't much of a risk given your other RBs.
0

Andy Cochrane (110 Reputation Points)
Giving away Colston and LeHoure is too much for Cruz. There is an argument that Colston is at least the equal of Cruz so I wouldn't do it personally.
0

Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)
I would rather keep Colston as well.. both are great options, but Cruz is not an upgrade to Colston.. More of a wash in my eyes.. Especially when he is healthy. I also think Colston is the best Wr you have..
0

Mark McGrath (500 Reputation Points)
Cruz is one of the top 4 receivers. Great to put in the lineup each week.
0

Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)
I really don't see Victor Cruz as an upgrade over Colston (unless you're worried about an injury), so I would stick with what you have.
0

al staton (500 Reputation Points)
Personally, I'd keep Colston and replace him with Fitz or Brown. Maybe this; LeShoure, Brown and Ballard for Cruz.
0

dong le (461 Reputation Points)
Keep colston, brees is going to throw 40+ every game while eli throws dep on the matchup.
0

Matthews (542 Reputation Points)
giving depth away for a significantly better wr imo....i would counter with colston and thomas or ballard and see what happens....but in the end i would find a way to upgrade from colston to cruz if possible