Ryan Mathews and Lance Moore for Brandon Lloyd and Ahmad Bradshaw who wins?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Yakov Schwalb

i have the mathews side

1

Tom Olp (500 Reputation Points)
You win. Bradshaw has shown that he is going to be a big part of the offensive game plan week in and week out, and Lloyd is bound to start finding the endzone. To see Bradshaw do what he did to the 49ers defense was incredibly encouraging for his rest of year rank. On the other side, Moore, while very talented, is unreliable in the Saints offense, as the production hasn't been consistent at all this year, and Mathews has not shown that he is ready to be a 1st round caliber runningback like he was perceived to be before the season started. I think this is a great offer for you.
0

Sysop (500 Reputation Points)
Both sides of the trade has upside, but i like the Lloyd/Bradshaw side better
Bradshaw has proven he can do it vs anyone after lighting up the 49rs
Never know how much battle is gonna get in SD
0

Matthews (542 Reputation Points)
id say its even really...mathews is more talented than bradshaw imo and both are fragile...lloyd is more talented to more imo but neither has been all that great this year. if anything i lean slightly to the mathews side because i feel like he will get more touches consistently personally