Questions
Trade Brady and Charles?
Should I trade tom Brady and Jamaal Charles for Arian Foster and Peyton Manning? non ppr league
My team
QB Tom Brady Joe Flacco Andrew Luck
RB Matt Forte Jamaal Charles Doug Martin Vick Ballard
WR Antonio Brown Percy Harvin Brandon Lloyd Brian Hartline Josh Gordon
TE Heath Miller Brandon Pettigrew
DST Cardinals
K Justin Tucker
  • 0
    reignman (446 Reputation Points)
    I would do it but you may want to trade for Ben Tate to back up Foster.
  • 0
    Hardliner1 (388 Reputation Points)
    With the overall depth you have, I say yes. Foster brings guaranteed points to your squad. Like Thomas said, Brady for Manning is a wash. Do it.
  • 0
    Andy Cochrane (110 Reputation Points)
    Yes but also drop Flacco for RB WR depth.
  • 0
    al staton (500 Reputation Points)
    Yes
  • 0
    Thomas Naughton (458 Reputation Points)
    I would. The Brady for Manning part is basically a wash (Manning has scored about 1 more point), but Foster is the undisputed king of RBs this year, having currently outscored Charles by more than 25 points. I also worry about Charles being able to hold up for the whole season as a lead back with really no one being able to spell him. So I would go get Foster and Manning and laugh at the idiot who proposed this one.
  • 0
    Tom Olp (500 Reputation Points)
    I'd say yes. Foster is such a reliable runner, and while Charles can explode for huge numbers, he can also lay an egg too. You know Foster will be in the game plan no matter what. When comparing Brady to Manning, neither of them is having consistently high numbers week in and week out, so the upgrade from Charles to Foster makes this trade worth it.
Question Tags
Jamaal Charles No Recent News
Tom Brady No Recent News
Question Tags
Jamaal Charles No Recent News
Tom Brady No Recent News