Questions
Who wins with this trade?
Aaron Hernandez, Jeremy Maclin, and Brandon Gibson for Martellus Bennett, Eric Decker and Darrius Heyward-Bey?
  • 2
    Eli Bogursky (301 Reputation Points)
    It's very close, but I'd lean to the Hernandez side. It seems like he will play this week against Seattle, and when healthy he is much better than Bennett. Decker is the best receiver in this deal, but Maclin is not too far behind. Hey-Bey and Gibson are both fliers, but I'd lead very slightly to Hey-Bey on that one. If you need receivers, take the Decker side, but if you need a tight end, take the Hernandez side.
    3 Comments
    Brandon Harris (544 Reputation Points)
    Thanks. If I trade Hernandez I'd have Finley left. He's a headache. My other recievers are Miles Austin and Mike Williams other than Gibson and Maclin...
    Eli Bogursky (301 Reputation Points)
    Then I'd just stand. if you're going to deal Hernandez or Finley, wait until one has a big week, then go for a second tier receiver.
    Matt Mannie (500 Reputation Points)
    i agree the hernandez side wins - but not that it's close...
  • 1
    Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)
    Not even close to me.. Maclin/Hernandez side wins. or it will be once Maclin has fully recovered
  • 1
    Matt Mannie (500 Reputation Points)
    in my opinion you would do your team much harm if you went through with this trade. see if you can put finley in place of hernandez maybe - but if not - i would stay put. good luck brandon
    1 Comment
    Brandon Harris (544 Reputation Points)
    Thanks. I'm holding on to what I got. Appreciate it.