Would you drop Mason Crosby?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

A&M_Consolidated

If so, for who? (Walsh, Tucker, Tynes, Graham, etc.)

1

Anton Deljaj (500 Reputation Points)
who cares? its a kicker...thats the most unpredictable and replaceable position on a roster. A kicker's points are in large part determined by how his offense handles the balls and the chances he gets FROM THEM, so even having a great kicker doesnt gaurantee you any more points than having a mediocre one
1

Keith Goldner (815 Reputation Points)
He's a kicker... doesn't really matter. Do what you gotta do
0

Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)
For me it's between Tynes and Walsh..
0

Andy Cochrane (110 Reputation Points)
I agree with the above. A kicker on a good team could often get fewer points than one on a mediocre team. If Green Bay scores 6 touchdowns then the kicker will only get 6 extra points. A kicker on a less good team can often score more points with field goals.
0

Josh Wade (500 Reputation Points)
Yes - Walsh>Tucker>Tynes>Graham