Questions
Nathan L
Trade Cobb/Harvin/Julio Jones for Jamaal Charles?
I have the opportunity to trade one of my receivers for Charles. Need to win the next two games, so performing in those two games is a premium for me. Basically, either the third receiver of that group, or Charles would be my flex (unless I decided to start Marcel Reese instead). Is it worth trading one of my WRs for Charles, and if so, which one?In my league we start 2 RBs, 2 WRs, and a Flex.
I have:
RB: Lynch, Morris, McFadden/Reese, Larod Stephens-Howling, Ingram
WR: Julio Jones, Harvin, Cobb, Hartline, Danario Alexander
Any thoughts would be really appreciated!
-
0adam schmidt (500 Reputation Points)Dude, I like your team, but if you're going to trade for Charles, I would give up Jones. The Harvin, then cobb. Cobb is on fire and not slowing down..1 Comment↳Nathan L (537 Reputation Points)Agreed. Going to keep Cobb for sure. I guess the main question becomes whether I adding Charles as a flex is a big upgrade over whoever I would chose from Reese/LSH/3rd WR based on matchups. Charles has the chance to explode but can't decide how big an upgrade he is over those guys . . .
-
0The Diesel (387 Reputation Points)Give up Jones2 Comments↳The Diesel (387 Reputation Points)JK your fine at running back you are weak at WR↳Nathan L (537 Reputation Points)Interesting. But if I'm looking to have the best starting lineup, you don't think that Charles would be an upgrade over whichever WR (or Reese) I would start at flex?
-
0Chris Marsh (500 Reputation Points)Agreed - giving up way too much. Cobb alone is going to do some damage the rest of the season.1 Comment↳Nathan L (537 Reputation Points)Sorry, just to clarify, I would only have to give up one of the WRs, not all 3. I was just asking which of the 3 I should give up (i.e. which two do I want to keep for the rest of the season) or whether I should keep all three and start the third at flex instead of Charles. Thoughts?
-
0Guillermo Joya (500 Reputation Points)wow
-
0Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)Hell NO!! giving up way too Much!!! Way too much! Julio/Charles or Cobb Charles is more fair, but I wouldn't want to get rid of Cobb now that Jordy is back.4 Comments↳Nathan L (537 Reputation Points)Sorry, just to clarify, I would only have to give up one of the WRs, not all 3. I was just asking which of the 3 I should give up (i.e. which two do I want to keep for the rest of the season) or whether I should keep all three and start the third at flex instead of Charles. Thoughts?↳Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)that makes more sense.. I think then I may give up Jones,.. Harvin is like Cobb with more upside being he is their #1 WR↳Nathan L (537 Reputation Points)True, plus he's hurt and I need him to perform this week. Do you think Charles is enough of an upgrade to be worth doing the deal?↳Anthony Best (381 Reputation Points)I don't know.. I just don't understand how KC is so bad with the talent they have on offensive side of ball.. Talent wise, Charles is easily enough of a upgrade.. but his team as a whole is a different story.. I would honestly look for a RB on a better team.
Jamaal Charles 
Julio Jones 
Randall Cobb