Trade Isaac Redman and Andy Dalton For Eli Manning and Nick Foles

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

al carlson

In a 2 Qb Leauge w/ Dalton, Vick, Smith as my qb's

0

BEAST MODE (607 Reputation Points)
Yes. Has anyone seen this Eli guy the last couple years at the end of seasons? Winning games when it matters and getting to those super bowl things? Keep him. I am.
0

Christopher Bast (500 Reputation Points)
Thats a bit more interesting, A.Dalton has the better hand right now but Eli is always better down the stretch of a season... I like Dalton a bit better right now, just because he's consist so far this season, but Eli has some good matchups coming up, minus the last two games in the playoffs vs ATL and BAL. (NOTE: Redman is good, but to much time share with Dwyer, and Mendy is back next week and has been named the for sure starter by Tomlin, and Foles.... well thats all questions marks there, the o-line is bad and... it's just not a good pickup i think). Hope this helps a bit.
0

Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)
No, I don't like this trade at all. Andy Dalton has been pretty consistent all year, while Eli has been garbage lately and we have no idea what to expect out of Nick Foles. If you could get Foles for cheap and still hang onto Dalton, then I would go for it.