NFL
NFL Betting: Best Values to Make and Miss the Playoffs
FanDuel Sportsbook has the Cleveland Browns as the eighth-most likely team to make the playoffs next season. Is there any value on that line?

Predicting which NFL team will make the playoffs looks easy on the surface, but it is more difficult than it seems.

It's like that carnival game Cat Rack, where the goal of the game is to toss three baseballs at a wall of clown puppets. If you knock down three puppets, you get to take home an oversized sloth stuffed animal that will lurk in the corner of your bedroom, gathering dust, for years to come. However, that sloth remains hanging from the rafters of the carnival game because your first toss magically splits the puppets. In frustration, you plop down five more dollars and start flame throwing fastballs as the disinterested carnival employee watches. You knock down the first two puppets and gain confidence. You wind up like Tim Lincecum for your final throw and clank it right off the padded railing, losing another Lincoln.

Among the 12 teams that made the playoffs in 2017, only 5 returned to make the playoffs the following season. While some teams seem like a shoo-in to make or miss the playoffs, there are always surprises. I took a look at the odds over at FanDuel's Sportsbook where you can bet on each NFL team to either make or miss the playoffs. I then calculated the implied odds from each moneyline and compared it to numberFire's projected playoff chances.

Team Name FanDuel Odds Implied Odds numberFire Odds Difference
Cincinnati Bengals +680 12.8% 22.3% 9.48
Denver Broncos +380 20.8% 30.2% 9.37
Buffalo Bills +410 19.6% 28.9% 9.29
Baltimore Ravens +174 36.5% 45.7% 9.20
Tampa Bay Buccaneers +500 16.7% 24.4% 7.73
New York Giants +530 15.9% 23.1% 7.23
Seattle Seahawks +130 43.4% 49.3% 5.82
Carolina Panthers +192 34.3% 39.3% 5.05
Houston Texans +146 40.7% 44.6% 3.95
Minnesota Vikings +138 42.0% 44.4% 2.38
Tennessee Titans +270 27.0% 28.9% 1.87
Dallas Cowboys +110 47.6% 49.4% 1.78
Pittsburgh Steelers +104 49.0% 50.8% 1.78
Detroit Lions +490 17.0% 18.2% 1.25
Chicago Bears -110 52.4% 53.3% 0.92
Washington Redskins +450 18.2% 15.5% -2.68
Arizona Cardinals +790 11.2% 7.9% -3.34
Miami Dolphins +790 11.2% 7.2% -4.04
Los Angeles Chargers -198 66.4% 62.0% -4.44
Philadelphia Eagles -172 63.2% 57.7% -5.54
New York Jets +300 25.0% 18.6% -6.40
San Francisco 49ers +210 32.3% 24.9% -7.36
Kansas City Chiefs -270 73.0% 65.1% -7.87
Green Bay Packers -104 51.0% 42.9% -8.08
Los Angeles Rams -280 73.7% 63.4% -10.28
Jacksonville Jaguars +205 32.8% 21.7% -11.09
New Orleans Saints -320 76.2% 65.1% -11.09
Oakland Raiders +470 17.5% 6.0% -11.54
New England Patriots -1150 92.0% 77.8% -14.20
Indianapolis Colts -178 64.0% 49.8% -14.23
Cleveland Browns -122 55.0% 40.5% -14.45
Atlanta Falcons +138 42.0% 21.2% -20.82

Best Bets to Make the Playoffs

The majority of the teams at the top of our list are underdogs. Of these teams, two in particular stand out.

Baltimore Ravens (+174)

The AFC North's offseason talk has been dominated by the Cleveland Browns and their seemingly inevitable return to winning. In addition, the Pittsburgh Steelers were in the headlines for drama with former players Antonio Brown and Le'Veon Bell. The Baltimore Ravens have flown under the radar. But that's what ravens do. Just like the three-eyed raven Bran Stark, you hang around long enough and then suddenly you are king.

The Ravens moneyline of +174 gives implied odds of 36.5% to make the playoffs, but numberFire gives them a much higher chance of 45.7%. While their offense is going to heavily depend on Lamar Jackson and the running game, their defense should be their strength. numberFire projects the Ravens to have the third best defense in the NFL.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers (+500)

I'm a sucker for Bruce Arians. He's known as the Quarterback Whisperer after improving the play of a young Ben Roethlisberger, Andrew Luck, and a "past his prime" Carson Palmer. If anyone can revive the career of Jameis Winston, it will be Arians.

The Buccaneers moneyline of +500 gives implied odds of 16.7% to make the playoffs but numberFire gives them a higher chance of 24.4%. While the Bucs are projected to have a bottom-five defense, their passing offense is projected to be the tenth best. Last season, the Bucs led the NFL in passing yards, with 5,125. With a passing attack featuring Mike Evans, Chris Godwin, and O.J. Howard, they still possess high upside.

Best Bets to Miss the Playoffs

Using the same logic as above, I cross-referenced numberFire's odds of missing the playoffs with the current odds over at FanDuel's Sportsbook.

Team Name FanDuel Odds Implied Odds numberFire Odds Difference
Atlanta Falcons -166 62.4% 78.8% 16.39
New England Patriots +700 12.5% 22.2% 9.70
Cleveland Browns +100 50.0% 59.5% 9.50
Indianapolis Colts +142 41.3% 50.2% 8.88
Oakland Raiders -700 87.5% 94.0% 6.50
New Orleans Saints +245 29.0% 34.9% 5.91
Jacksonville Jaguars -270 73.0% 78.3% 5.33
Los Angeles Rams +215 31.8% 36.6% 4.85
Green Bay Packers -118 54.1% 57.1% 2.97
Kansas City Chiefs +210 32.2% 34.9% 2.64
San Francisco 49ers -270 73.0% 75.1% 2.13
New York Jets -410 80.4% 81.4% 1.01
Philadelphia Eagles +140 41.7% 42.3% 0.63
Los Angeles Chargers +160 38.5% 38.0% -0.46
Miami Dolphins -1450 93.6% 92.8% -0.75
Arizona Cardinals -1300 92.9% 92.1% -0.76
Washington Redskins -650 86.7% 84.5% -2.17
Chicago Bears -110 52.4% 46.7% -5.68
Detroit Lions -700 87.5% 81.8% -5.70
Dallas Cowboys -134 57.3% 50.6% -6.66
Tennessee Titans -350 77.8% 71.1% -6.68
Minnesota Vikings -166 62.4% 55.6% -6.81
Pittsburgh Steelers -128 56.1% 49.2% -6.94
Houston Texans -182 64.5% 55.4% -9.14
Seattle Seahawks -156 60.9% 50.7% -10.24
Carolina Panthers -245 71.0% 60.7% -10.31
Tampa Bay Buccaneers -700 87.5% 75.6% -11.90
New York Giants -800 88.9% 76.9% -11.99
Baltimore Ravens -220 68.8% 54.3% -14.45
Cincinnati Bengals -1200 92.3% 77.7% -14.61
Buffalo Bills -600 85.7% 71.1% -14.61
Denver Broncos -550 84.6% 69.8% -14.82

Atlanta Falcons (-166)

Unsurprisingly, the chart above is essentially an inverse of teams projected to make the playoffs. Our largest discrepancy lies with the Atlanta Falcons. After making it to the playoffs in 2016 and 2017, the Falcons went 7-9 last year and failed to appear. FanDuel's odds imply that they have a 62.41% chance of missing the playoffs but numberFire is strongly against the Falcons, giving them a 78.8% chance of missing the playoffs.

Our projections rate the Falcons as having the tenth best offense but the thirtieth ranked defense in the NFL, projecting them to tie for the seventh-fewest wins in the league.

Cleveland Browns (+100)

The Browns are the most popular Super Bowl bet of the offseason. I'm surprised my computer even let me type that out. 2003 was the last time that the Browns made the playoffs, and their offense was led by the dynamic duo of Kelly Holcomb and Dennis Northcutt. This surge in popularity has led to the Browns being overvalued.

The betting lines give the Browns only a 50% chance of missing the playoffs, but numberFire gives them a 59.5% chance of missing out. The Browns are in a division with the aforementioned Ravens and the Pittsburgh Steelers, who have never had a losing season in twelve years under Mike Tomlin. The road to the playoffs will be bumpy for the Browns.

Related News

An Introduction to FanDuel Research

Jim Sannes  --  Jul 15th, 2019

The Late-Round Fantasy Football Podcast, Mailbag 7/21/23

JJ Zachariason  --  Jul 15th, 2019

The Late-Round Fantasy Football Podcast, Approaching Unique Leagues

JJ Zachariason  --  Jul 15th, 2019