Questions
Andrew Kilman
Should I do this trade
I have both Ben Roethlisberger and Eli Manning. They have the same bye week so I was going to drop Ben anyway, but I got offered a trade so I was wondering if any of you would do this. Ben and Rishard Matthews for Calvin Johnson?
-
2WB (487 Reputation Points)No on the trade and I wouldn't drop Ben, I'd drop Eli instead.
-
1-VSOP- (359 Reputation Points)Really? Drop Ben? Drop Eli instead. You can try and trade Eli/Watkins for Calvin but I wouldn't do it. Try Watkins/Rishard and see if they bite.
-
0reignman (446 Reputation Points)do not trade away ben. doesn't matter what else you do, but don't trade away a guy who has that many weapons and wolverine's healing ability. eli will eventually sh*t the bed. calvin is not what he once was. he's good but the megatron days are probably gone.
-
0Lenny Frazier (366 Reputation Points)with the way Detroit has played this season I wouldn't make the trade , and Ben , when healthy is a top 10 Qb. Sanchez will get better timing with his receivers so look forward to Matthews to be productive.
-
0Kyle Albright (343 Reputation Points)i wouldnt either. matthews is going to produce better than johnson the rest of the year.
-
0Danilo Corrons (506 Reputation Points)No. I have Calvin Johnson and I'm actually looking to trade him away. He has been under performing all year and I don't think it's going to change. I would try to trade Ben to someone for a WR straight up. Considering you have Eli and although I don't think he is as good as Ben, his SOS is better than Ben's and he should produce 20+ points consistently.2 Comments↳Andrew Kilman (554 Reputation Points)Would you do the same trade with Ben and Sammy Watkins for Calvin. I just dont want to drop Ben and get nothing in return↳Kyle Albright (343 Reputation Points)i would play ben no matter the matchup. he will be more consistent than manning 330/2 tds each game. especially with deangelo as the RB. hes good, but no Bell.
Ben Roethlisberger 
Calvin Johnson 
Rishard Matthews