Questions
Keeper league - Alshon or Megatron?
I'm in a league where you can keep two every year, basically taking your first 2 picks of the draft. Who would you keep: Calvin Johnson or Alshon Jeffery? My other keeper is CJ Anderson. I'll have a late 3rd round pick after the keepers are taken.
  • 0
    Small Paul (479 Reputation Points)
    I generally agree with Ajay & Alex. But would add that when you draft could make a difference and you could perhaps be able to get both the players. But yes, go with Megatron!
  • 0
    Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)
    If it's the same penalty for both I'd say Megatron, he's the better player and has the better QB
  • 0
    Ajay Sutton (383 Reputation Points)
    So everyone's keepers equate to their first two picks? If so, I'd just pick the better player...which for me, is Megatron.
    2 Comments
    Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)
    Yeah. I agree. The caveat being a keeper league with Megatron getting older (and hurt) and Jeffrey could be on the rise to be a top fantasy receiver as the number 1. I'm probably over thinking.
    Ajay Sutton (383 Reputation Points)
    I don't think you're overthinking. I would agree with you in a dynasty format, but in a keeper league, who knows who your keepers will end up being. I doubt anyone keeping Jeremy Hill and Odell Beckham this year thought they would be doing so last year. Its more of a short-term roster construction mindset in a keeper league, and for this year, I just liked Calvin more. Jeffery is not a bad option at all, but even with some of the signs of aging that he's shown, Calvin Johnson is still the better keep.
Question Tags
Calvin Johnson No Recent News
Alshon Jeffery No Recent News
Question Tags
Calvin Johnson No Recent News
Alshon Jeffery No Recent News