Questions
Jeremy
Keeper league - Alshon or Megatron?
I'm in a league where you can keep two every year, basically taking your first 2 picks of the draft. Who would you keep: Calvin Johnson or Alshon Jeffery? My other keeper is CJ Anderson. I'll have a late 3rd round pick after the keepers are taken.
-
0Small Paul (479 Reputation Points)I generally agree with Ajay & Alex. But would add that when you draft could make a difference and you could perhaps be able to get both the players. But yes, go with Megatron!
-
0Alex Venti (520 Reputation Points)If it's the same penalty for both I'd say Megatron, he's the better player and has the better QB
-
0Ajay Sutton (383 Reputation Points)So everyone's keepers equate to their first two picks? If so, I'd just pick the better player...which for me, is Megatron.2 Comments↳Jeremy (517 Reputation Points)Yeah. I agree. The caveat being a keeper league with Megatron getting older (and hurt) and Jeffrey could be on the rise to be a top fantasy receiver as the number 1. I'm probably over thinking.↳Ajay Sutton (383 Reputation Points)I don't think you're overthinking. I would agree with you in a dynasty format, but in a keeper league, who knows who your keepers will end up being. I doubt anyone keeping Jeremy Hill and Odell Beckham this year thought they would be doing so last year. Its more of a short-term roster construction mindset in a keeper league, and for this year, I just liked Calvin more. Jeffery is not a bad option at all, but even with some of the signs of aging that he's shown, Calvin Johnson is still the better keep.