Trade Advice: Murray/Brady for Nelson/Peyton

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

JEG

Trade Advice: Murray/Brady for Nelson/Peyton

8 team, 0.5 PPR league. My relevant players:
QB: Brady, Cutler
RB: Murray, Foster, Charles, Hillman, Bell
WR: Megatron, Benjamin, Garcon, Andre Johnson, Hopkins, Gordon

I have an awesome top 3 RBs, with Hillman (another potential top-10 guy) on my bench. Another team in my league (who has Peyton Manning) needs RB help, and has offered Nelson for Charles or Murray, but I think the top RBs should be more valuable than a top WR.

If I included a Brady/Peyton swap, would that be fair, or am I reaching? Doing this trade would leave me with Foster/Charles at RB, Calvin/Jordy at WR, and flex choices in Hillman, Benjamin, and eventually Gordon.

0

Dirk Dirkowitz (411 Reputation Points)
I like the trade as you have it set up, and with the value of RBs and the season Murray's having, I don't think it's at all unreasonable. You're dreaming if you think Hillman cracks the top-10, but he's a fine backup for Foster and Charles.