Would you do this trade?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Blake Metropoulos

Would you do this trade?

Trade away Jerick MacKinnon and Roddy White to get Emmanuel Sanders? My team consists of:

QB: Russell Wilson/Stafford
RB1: Marshawn Lynch
RB2: Ronie Hillman
WR1: Antonio Brown
WR2: Doug Baldwin
TE: Zach Ertz

BENCH:
Jerick McKinnon
Roddy White
Reggie Wayne
Jordan Cameron
Rueben Randle
DeAngelo Williams

2

Dirk Dirkowitz (411 Reputation Points)
That's close. Sanders is a good upgrade over White, and that probably balances out dropping from McKinnon to Hillman. The only reason I'd hesitate is that it leaves you without a second clear-cut #1 back. Not that there are any guarantees in football, but McKinnon has a much better lock on his volume than Hillman (Ball returning) and Williams (RBBC). You just have to decide if you think you're getting enough of an upgrade to balance out the risk.
1 Comment

↳

Blake Metropoulos (360 Reputation Points)
I figured that Hillman had more value than McKinnon. What would you say if I traded Hillman instead of McKinnon?
1

Scott Ballard (385 Reputation Points)
Ehhhh this is a tough one. I think you do it only because McKinnon isn't the short yardage back which limits TD's