Please help me pick from these two offers!

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Wolf H.

Please help me pick from these two offers!

Here's the setup: 2-QB PPR Keeper League (up to 4 keepers)

Which should I do?
Trade 1: Send Bernard Get Nelson
Trade 2: Send Ryan and McKinnon Get Wilson and Watkins

QB: Peyton Manning
QB: Matt Ryan
RB: Giovani Bernard
RB: Ahmad Bradshaw
WR: Demaryius Thomas
WR: Calvin Johnson (when healthy)
WR: Keenan Allen
FX: Jerick McKinnon
TE: Greg Olsen

Bench:
Branden Oliver
Joique Bell
Brandin Cooks
Allen Robinson
Mohamed Sanu
Jordan Reed
Mike Glennon

1

Chris Moser (525 Reputation Points)
Neither. You need Bernard more than Nelson and McKinnon more than Watkins.
4 Comments

↳

Chris Moser (525 Reputation Points)
The only way you make one of these trades is if you plan on keeping Watkins. Even then, McKinnon is a great guy to keep.

↳

Wolf H. (569 Reputation Points)
No my Keeper would be Thomas and Johnson for sure. Then likely Manning for one more year and either Ryan or Gio. McKinnon is gonna a stud but I'm trying to win this year. If I traded Gio for Jordy then I have 3 of the best 5 wideouts to keep plus Manning for next year.

↳

Chris Moser (525 Reputation Points)
McKinnon helps you win this year. He's good. Gio really helps you win this year. I'd honestly rather keep Watkins than Manning too.

↳

Wolf H. (569 Reputation Points)
I'll have a tough decision for sure but since it is two QB you need to have at least one stud to compete. I'm 7-1 but in second place because the other guy has Rodgers, Luck, Murray, and Forte. You can see my predicament lol.
0

Michael Rehal (593 Reputation Points)
agree. denver had their bye, so you don't need QB depth. neither of these teams make your team any better. in theory, you could trade bernard, get nelson then trade any of your WRs for a top RB, but that might be unlikely.