Questions
As commish, would you allow this trade?
10 team, standard.

Aaron Rodgers
Jeremy Maclin
Bills D

for

Tony Romo
Larry Fitzgerald
Eric Decker
Alfred Morris
Andre Williams

The guy getting Rodgers and Maclin is 5-2 in 2nd place. He won the league last year on what I would consider a semi suspect trade.

The guy giving up Rodgers and Maclin is 1-6, in last place. The reasoning he told me for doing the trade was "damned if I do, damned if I don't. I'm 1-6 and staying the current course means catastrophic failure continues. Something brash must be done"
  • 0
    David Carroll (248 Reputation Points)
    I am on the fence about this one. Maclin hasn't exactly lit it up this year. Ertz is tied for the TD lead on Philly with 2 and is the leading receiver on the team with a little over 300 yards (320?). The 4 positional players going to the last place team are all suffering this year. Fitz and Morris both have the potential for a big game every now and then. Decker and Williams are barely ownable. When Jennings comes back in the next 2 weeks, Williams will be the after thought.

    So, it really comes down to a QB vs QB trade. Romo, historically, begins his annual collapse in the next few weeks. Will this year be any different? Rodgers is on fire with some people saying he is better this year than he was in the 2011 MVP year.

    The more I think about it, the more I don't like the trade.
  • 0
    Shawn L (444 Reputation Points)
    Well 1-6 is time for home run swings and drastic measures but not stupid ones with ZERO upside to ANY of the players hes getting in return, Fitz & Williams are almost not even own-able. If he needs RB's I totally get that but take out the QB's in this deal or else its way unfair.
Question Tags
Aaron Rodgers No Recent News
Jeremy Maclin No Recent News
Larry Fitzgerald No Recent News
Tony Romo No Recent News
Question Tags
Aaron Rodgers No Recent News
Jeremy Maclin No Recent News
Larry Fitzgerald No Recent News
Tony Romo No Recent News