Log in to numberFire

To get the full benefits of numberFire, please log in.

You'll get the best projections in the business!

Don't have an account? Click here to sign up!

Start Winning In Seconds

To get the full benefits of numberFire, please sign up.

You'll get the best projections in the business!

By registering, you indicate that you agree to the Terms Of Service.

Already have an account? Click here to log in!
Questions
Ask Question +
Zack Donahue
Trade Review
Team One
QB Wilson
RB Lynch
RB Vereen
WR Marshall
WR A Johnson
TE Thomas
Flex D Walker
D Ravens
K Hauschka
Bench Rivers, Hopkins Royal

Team 2
Qb Stafford
RB Tate
RB A Williams
WR Randle
WR A Holmes
TE Cameron
Flex T Williams
D Cowboys
K Gano
Bench as of now. Megatron, AJ Green, Jennings, Watkins, Dalton, D Allen

Team 2 wants to send AJ & megatron to team 1 For A Johnson & marshall
Is this a fair trade? i really don't thinks so. maybe its close now but in a couple weeks i think if team 1 has all that its unfair
  • 1
    Gregg Gregg (276 Reputation Points)
    If you trying to determine if its collusion, ask the guy who is trading AJ and Megatron why he is doing the deal. If he honestly thinks that its a good deal that will help him win, then you are just looking too much into how owners value other players.
    2 Comments
    ↳
    Zack Donahue (250 Reputation Points)
    He just doesn't want to play anymore he's trying to shop his two non drops for anything so he can't drop his whole team
    ↳
    Gregg Gregg (276 Reputation Points)
    Well if he drops his whole team (or attempts to) that is entirely different scenario. In that case you tell him either he needs to manage his team or you will get someone else to to take his spot in the league. If you cant, and he still doesnt want to play, move all the players back on his roster and lock his team. Had to deal with a similar issue in one of my leagues.
  • 0
    Sean Leto (552 Reputation Points)
    No, simple answer. That trade is not close to fair. Marshal will have better weeks and could end in top 10, but both Green and Calvin are top 5 guys. U could argue maybe 1 for 1 because of the injuries and needing to get a win, but shipping both feels pretty suspect.
  • 0
    Ryan Evans (444 Reputation Points)
    Two dinged up, who-knows-for-sure-when-they'll-be-back WR1s for a couple of reliable, playing-right-now WR2s? It's doable, though I think a clear win for Team 1. I wouldn't trade AJ and Megatron away for that if I was Team 2, but if that came across for me to review as a fellow owner, I certainly wouldn't veto it.
    1 Comment
    ↳
    Zack Donahue (250 Reputation Points)
    roto says aj will more than likely be back next week and Johnson is 50/50
  • 0
    Heisenberg (482 Reputation Points)
    What are both teams records? Team 2 might be desperate for wins and scared AJ and Megatron won't come back this weekend.
    3 Comments
    ↳
    Zack Donahue (250 Reputation Points)
    team 1 has 1 loss team 2 has one win
    ↳
    Blake (351 Reputation Points)
    I would veto it then. It is obvious why they are doing this.
    ↳
    Heisenberg (482 Reputation Points)
    Team 2 desperate for wins and can't afford to lose again. With Megatron not looking good for this weekend and Green questionable, I get the reasoning behind it.
  • 0
    Greg Thomas (449 Reputation Points)
    Marshall has been battling injuries all season and Andre Johnson seems to be a huge decline. I don't think it is worth it to trade 2 studs in Megtron and AJ. Be patient, they will be back and much stronger with all the rest. If you can try to spin another trade but this is blatantly a bad trade.
Question Tags
Calvin Johnson No Recent News
NFL
Related Questions
Question Tags
Calvin Johnson No Recent News
NFL