Should I do this trade?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Ankit Monga

Should I do this trade?

Should I trade my Eddie Lacy and Frank Gore for Giovani Bernard? I'm in a full point ppr league that gives a 5 point bonus at 100 yards rushing/receiving...Should I do it?

Qb: Cam Newton
Rb: Arian Foster
Rb: Eddie Lacy
Wr: Kelvin Benjamin
Wr: Antonio Brown
Te: Greg Olsen
Flex: Keenan Allen
K: Justin Tucker
DST: Patriots DST

Bench:

Frank Gore
James Starks
Markus Wheaton
Dolphins DST
Alfred Blue
Kendall Wright
Calvin Johnson

1

Heisenberg (482 Reputation Points)
I like this trade. I still like Lacy, but he's more of a TD dependent RB2 while splitting snaps with Starks. In PPR Gio is a top 5 back, so it's a clear upgrade for me. And the cost of the upgrade is Frank Gore? Yes please. Gore is a TD dependent RB2/3 and extremely replaceable. You can find another RB3 somewhere that is better than Gore.
1 Comment

↳

Sean Leto (552 Reputation Points)
I'd take whatever I could for Gore right now. He is only going to get slower.
0

Sean Leto (552 Reputation Points)
Disagree, I would scope up Gio in a heart beat if I could. If you asked this question 3 weeks ago when Gio was on top of the world in Cinnci, it would be a no brainer. Cinnci will get back on track and bio will finish in top 5 of Rb's this yr.
0

Dirk Dirkowitz (411 Reputation Points)
I think that's not necessarily bad value ... but I'd be worried about where that leaves you. Even without looking up bye weeks, I'd want to have a better backup than Starks in case Foster goes down with an injury. Or even Gio, for that matter.
0

Ryan Evans (444 Reputation Points)
Didn't this already get asked today...?

No. Leaves you too thin at RB.