Log in to numberFire

To get the full benefits of numberFire, please log in.

You'll get the best projections in the business!

Don't have an account? Click here to sign up!

Start Winning In Seconds

To get the full benefits of numberFire, please sign up.

You'll get the best projections in the business!

By registering, you indicate that you agree to the Terms Of Service.

Already have an account? Click here to log in!
Questions
Ask Question +
Jason Winer
Blockbuster Trade
Looks like an owner in my league wants out of the Chiefs offense has proposed to me:

I get: Charles, Knile Davis, Jeremy Maclin
I give: McCoy

RBs: McCoy, Pierre Thomas, Fred Jackson, Steven Jackson, Alfred Blue
WRs: Garcon, Crabtree, Benjamin, Steve Smith

Discuss!
  • 0
    Bridog (725 Reputation Points)
    This is really a tough call. I don't know that I would want to take an an existing injury/handcuff situation in Charles/Davis when you already have a single, healthy, elite RB1 in McCoy. If you had any other somewhat comparable but lesser RB like an Ellington or Morris, I would try to involve them in the trade instead. Unfortunately, you don't have a ton of depth at RB, which would make me even less inclined to involve my head-and-shoulders-above-the-rest RB in any trades. On the other hand, you could really use Maclin at WR, so I don't know. You have to decide if Maclin is worth giving up McCoy for a potential headache situation with Charles/Davis. If it's me, I think I would probably decline this trade, but still try to make a deal somewhere for a WR, either with this guy for just Maclin, or from another guy in the league.
  • 0
    Shahum Chaudhry (291 Reputation Points)
    This is a tough one!

    Maclin Would be a great addition to your receiving core.
    But the way the chiefs offense has been struggling I feel Mccoy has more upside than Charles. Mccoy is the number one RB in philly in terms of touches, sproles won't take away too much from that.

    I think what will end up happening is a time share scenario in Kansas city with Charles/davis. Both are capable of being every down RB, where as I feel sproles is not.

    Good Luck!
  • 0
    Jim Halpin (488 Reputation Points)
    do it. high ankle sprains are a nagging injury. he was already back at practice today but i think he is trying to gut it out which will only lead to a bigger problem if it isn't totally healed.
    2 Comments
    ↳
    Jason Winer (576 Reputation Points)
    So why would I want Charles then? In the proposed trade I'd be getting him.
    ↳
    Jim Halpin (488 Reputation Points)
    oh..woops. read that wrong. thought you were getting mccoy
  • 0
    Rate my wife (551 Reputation Points)
    Yes, I would pull the trigger.

    Maclin will help your wr's and Charles/Davis and Mccoy are pretty much even. Mccoy is now in a timeshare as could charles when he gets back.

    Depend on your view of how well Charles will play upon returning from injury.
Question Tags
Jamaal Charles No Recent News
Jeremy Maclin No Recent News
LeSean McCoy No Recent News
Knile Davis No Recent News
NFL
Related Questions
Question Tags
Jamaal Charles No Recent News
Jeremy Maclin No Recent News
LeSean McCoy No Recent News
Knile Davis No Recent News
NFL