Cam Newton & Julius Thomas for Golden Tate and Andre Johnson? Accept?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Richard Calura

Cam Newton & Julius Thomas for Golden Tate and Andre Johnson? Accept?

Trade proposal: Good trade? Go for it? I'll get a back up QB and another TE. Flex is WR/TE, so I would be playing Gronk and J. Thomas at the same time. I have decent WR's on my bench or am I giving up too much with Tate and Johnson? Thanks for any help and advice.

10 Team PPR League

QB: Tom Brady
WR: Jordy Nelson
WR: Andre Johnson
RB: Jamal Charles
RB: DeMarco Murray
TE: Rob Gronkowski
WR/TE: Cordarelle Patterson
DEF: Chicago
K: Dan Bailey

BN: Toby Gerhart
BN: Ben Tate
BN: Golden Tate
BN: Kelvin Benjamin
BN: Mike Evans
BN: Dennis Pitta

1

Angel Reed (105 Reputation Points)
If you're getting back Julius Thomas, I do that trade without a second thought lol, Cam is a top 5 qb usually too. Also check out my question if you can, I really need help there.
0

Matthews (542 Reputation Points)
id do it if you think you can flip gronk for something of good value, but im not loving keeping 3 te all year
0

Noah Hilton (500 Reputation Points)
I wouldn't do it. You already have 2 TEs, and Newton's looking like kind of an injury risk. No need to have a back-up QB, Brady's solid enough. I don't get the advantage of having Gronk and Thomas. They're stars because they stand out at their position. Compare their #s to those of WRs and the WRs win every time. Think you're better off with Tate and Johnson.
0

Justin Roland (308 Reputation Points)
I wouldn't do it. Its a complex trade, and there are a few scenarios where that trade works out, but Andre Johnson is your starting WR. If Newton doesn't stay healthy, he may not be an upgrade over Brady. Essentially you are giving up your WR2 and a PPR flex option in Tate for Julius Thomas and a QB who may or may not improve your team.