Pick a side: Peyton Manning for Jordy Nelson and Andrew Luck

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Chase McAnulty

Regardless of needs, what would you do straight up here in trade? I have Carson Palmer as backup QB and Julio Jones and Wes Welker as main WRs

1

aaron lijewski (289 Reputation Points)
Id keep jordy nelson and andrew luck
0

Hardliner1 (388 Reputation Points)
Peyton is always good, but I highly doubt he'll have the type of season he had last year. I think Luck and Jordy will give you an upside. I say keep those two. Dude is nuts if he gives up Peyton anyhow.
0

Matthews (542 Reputation Points)
id rather have jordy and luck
0

zack borglum (500 Reputation Points)
the jordy and luck side all day. manning is most likely going to see a regression towards the mean (he isn't putting up 55 touches again although 5000 yds is likely) but luck is only going to get better. jordy is the only guy outside of the big names (calvin dez DT Aj Marshall julio n Brown if ppr) that has a legit chance to be the #1 wr. he is a touchdown machine and the favorite weapon for arguably the best qb. also not one team in that division knows how to play defense anymore and all besides the vikings have extremely good Off meaning shootouts galore.
0

Sam Hauss (371 Reputation Points)
Jordy side is the right side