Keeper Advice

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Brandon Arnold

Keeper Advice

This is for a 12 team keeper league (Down from 16), no PPR. I need to keep four and I will get to pick starting in the 5th Round. Who should I keep:
Lesean McCoy
DeMarco Murray
Montee Ball
Arian Foster
Cam Newton
Victor Cruz
Randall Cobb

2

Leo Kaliski (322 Reputation Points)
I'd say keep McCoy, Murray, Ball, and Cobb. Foster is a big risk, Cruz could be in another awful offense, and I wouldn't personally take Cam before the 5th.
3 Comments

↳

Kevin Waida (541 Reputation Points)
Ball is a bigger risk than foster. Foster MIGHT get hurt. Ball WILL get pulled the first block he misses or the first time he fumbles. Just like last season

↳

Leo Kaliski (322 Reputation Points)
Ball got pulled so quick last season because Moreno was right behind with solid pass protection and ball security. This time he's not there, and the guys behind him have had the same problems as Ball. I don't think Ball get's pulled after one mistake this year, he's got a much longer leash. Meanwhile Foster is on the wrong side of 3 years with 300+ carries and is coming off major surgery. Not saying it's clear cut, but I think Ball is less risky.

↳

Nicholas Tidd (500 Reputation Points)
Leo has the right picks, I would say. McCoy (no brainer), Murray, if healthy is an RB1, Cobb going in the fourth (per your keeper draft) is solid value and I definitely like Cobb over Cruz. QB is so damn deep, you can find many tasty treats in the mid late rounds and beyond e.g., Cutler, Romo, Rivers, Ryan, Wilson. The real question is between Foster/Ball. Numberfire says Arian but not by much. Foster is a workhorse, Ball is unproven. I like Ball's situation a lot more especially since we are talking about your RB#
0

Sam Hauss (371 Reputation Points)
If you are keeping 4, all in your first four picks, I would go with Shady/DeMarco/Cobb/Cruz. Although, if you have a flex spot I would strongly prefer going with Shady/DeMarco/Ball/Cobb, especially in a non-PPR.
0

m f (500 Reputation Points)
Keep all the RB's and trade for the top WR of your choice.
0

Darren Manser (500 Reputation Points)
I'm dropping Cruz for sure...and then toss up between Foster and Cam..I'd probably drop Cam especially if u start 2 flex