What do you think of this trade?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Zach Brunner

Standard scoring league. The trade is Murray, Wallace, Clay for Gio, Bowe, Pitta.

2

Dirty Randy's (482 Reputation Points)
Who ever gets Murray gets the better deal. Murray better then Gio. Wallace better than Bowe. pitta could be better than clay and probably will.
1 Comment

↳

Rob S (432 Reputation Points)
exactly my thoughts.
0

Beau Ryan (500 Reputation Points)
Murray Wallace Clay so much better, not even close.
0

Matt Mannie (500 Reputation Points)
i like the bernard side - see my reply to kc - just thoughts though and he is pretty right on, so - take this with a grain of salt, but i would do it
0

brickthrees (500 Reputation Points)
Agree with everyone, the Murray side wins. Murray is a bigger, more dynamic back than Gio.
1 Comment

↳

Matt Mannie (500 Reputation Points)
bigger yes - more dynamic...not even close
0

Azad Armani (500 Reputation Points)
I like Pitta a little more this year than Clay, but wouldn't give up Murray for him. Keep Murray
0

Kacee Giger (624 Reputation Points)
I hope this trade is just theoretical or you're deciding whether to accept or not as otherwise the side getting Gio\Bowe\Pitta just got hosed. In my opinion, Murray >> Gio, Wallace > Bowe, and Clay > Pitta in all formats.
1 Comment

↳

Matt Mannie (500 Reputation Points)
with all due respect, i like the other side...assuming gio is bernard - that side wins. no way murray plays 16 games, miami's line is all new - or re-vamped - as they put it, meaning tany will be on life support at some point and if pitta can return to end of 2012 form - big win for that side...imo