Who do I land as my keeper?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Sam Hoppen

Who do I land as my keeper?

I've got Manning, McCoy, and Graham available as keepers, all of whom I'd have to use my first round pick to take when I choose one of them. Everything I read points to McCoy because he's easily a top-3 overall pick, but Graham has been such a stud the past couple years and seems to be on a level of his own in terms of tight end. I'm hesitant about Manning because I don't think he'll repeat the year he had last year, and, like McCoy, I think there are a couple other viable options at their respective position. Let me know what you think. If I wanted, I could also go with Jordy Nelson as a fifth round pick, but his production heavily relies on Rodgers' health, and I'm a little worried about that.

4

JJ Zachariason (411 Reputation Points)
Easily McCoy. Peyton and Graham don't play scarce positions, and McCoy is one of the few guys who should be a lock, barring injury, to keep his pace at RB. I'm actually not against Jordy in the 5th if you can guarantee drafting McCoy or another top-tier back. That's actually the most optimal move in my eyes.
2 Comments

↳

Derek Archer (500 Reputation Points)
Totally agree.

↳

G M (391 Reputation Points)
Ditto.
0

Zan Patorgis (500 Reputation Points)
It kind of depends where you pick in the first round. If you're in the top half of the 1st and you get a crack at any of Peterson, McCoy, Charles, Forte, Lacy, or Murray, then I would keep Nelson for the 5th.