Would you make this trade?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Warren Rixon

Would you make this trade?

Gio, DJax, Jordan Cameron and Maclin for Marshall, Spiller, Foles and Martellus Bennett

Current QB is Kaepernick (may need to chuck him in, but Foles is the backup for the guy I'm trading with), other RBs are Forte, Murray and Sankey & other WRs are VJax, Torrey Smith, Hopkins and rookies.

Would you still do it if you could instead get Montee for Gio + Devonta Freeman?

2

Scott (500 Reputation Points)
QB: Foles in most likely going to regress a bit this year, and will probably end up lower than Kaep. So this won't help much
RB: Spiller has upside, but he has proven to be inconsistent. Meanwhile, Gio is in for a bigger workload and has a ton of upside as well. I'd say this is a downgrade at RB.
WR: Marshall is clearly better than DJax and Maclin. I'd rather have Marshall and some random WR than the combo of DJax and Maclin.
TE: Cameron will most likely grade out better than Bennett by the end of year.

So while you get a major force at WR in Marshall, I think it doesn't help you in enough other spots. I would not make this trade.
1

Raghav Saini (380 Reputation Points)
I'd only say yes if you needed a QB, but you don't. Trust Kaepernick and his "untapped" potential.
1

Sahib Bennett (320 Reputation Points)
WR: Marshall is slightly higher ranked. But DJax will be playing with a HUGE chip on his shoulder (No pun intended).
RB: Gio is higher ranked than Spiller. Spiller cant be trusted to stay healhty. And FJax isnt going anywhere anytime soon.
TE: Cameron is higher ranked than Bennett. Cameron will be the star of the Cleveland passing game.
Maclin vs Foles: I LOVE this Philly offense. I see Maclin doing big things in Philly. He is VERY underrated.

Stand pat. If you arent comfortable with Kaep, do another deal and see what else you can get Foles for.
1

Eamonn Choukrane (665 Reputation Points)
Yeah, Gio and Freeman sure. Even trade. Go either way. I'm big on spiller so...
0

Raghav Saini (380 Reputation Points)
I'd only say yes if you needed a QB, but you don't. Trust Kaepernick and his "untapped" potential.