Keeper League: Who do I keep?

Questions

To vote or ask a question, please login or !

Rian Libich

Keeper League: Who do I keep?

I can keep 1 of these players. I won't need to make a final decision until the end of summer. What do you guys think?

RB: DeMarco Murray, Le'Veon Bell, Giovani Bernard, Stevan Ridley, Ryan Matthews

WR: A.J. Green, Brandon Marshall, Roddy White, Hakeem Nicks

1

KamakuraKid (500 Reputation Points)
In my league, we can retain up to three Keepers. The additional cost: $10, $15, $20 for the third, all over and above the $100 league fee. You can only mark players as a Keeper if taken after round five. Each year the Keeper moves up a round the following year, you lose the Keeper no matter what when he moves to round two. So it depends, do you lose a round? If so where? I am keeping J. Nelson (round 6), L. Bell (round 11) and J. Gordon (round 9) as all were taken in rounds 6 and later. I am set for next year... taken three years to get here and many errors... speaking to you McFadden!
2 Comments

↳

Rian Libich (500 Reputation Points)
I'm actually the Commisioner for the league and have never made one before. I really like your breakdown and I think I'll probably follow close to your format. How do Keeper cost work?

↳

KamakuraKid (500 Reputation Points)
Keeper #1 is $20, #2 is $15 and #3 is $10. It looks like the 2016 season we will be bumping up the Keepers by $5 on each level as everyone kept three Keepers. I've looked at the past five years data, Keepers were busts nearly 60% of the time. For what that is worth, add to it the record of first round picks being busts half the time and really it is all about in-season skills determining your team success. We have 30 Waiver List Pick ups per season, I max out every year by game 15, we have 16 games in the season.
0

Eamonn Choukrane (665 Reputation Points)
is there any round associated with these players or any round penalty? I would only even consider: Murray, bell, bernard, green and marshall
0

Keith Goldner (815 Reputation Points)
Is there a keeper cost? I think A.J. Green is best out of those guys, but really depends on your keeper rules/league settings and costs. Bell, Murray and Marshall would all be close (maybe even Bernard)
1 Comment

↳

BEAST MODE (607 Reputation Points)
agree AJ is the one. the RBs are all solid but non are top 10, while AJ is top 5 WR, esp if you are in PPR league