Peyton Manning

View Player Page

How will the Indianapolis Colts do this season?
Asked in: Adam Vinatieri, Anthony Gonzalez, Austin Collie, Blair White, Dallas Clark, Delone Carter, Donald Brown, Indianapolis D/ST, Jacob Tamme, Javarris James, Joseph Addai, Mike Hart, Peyton Manning, Pierre Garcon, Reggie Wayne

0Keith Goldner
You can never bet against Peyton and crew. They'll be in the playoffs for sure. Always looking forward to the Colts/Patriots post-season showdown.

Who is a better draft pick: Michael Vick or Peyton Manning?
Asked in: Michael Vick, Peyton Manning, Quarterbacks, Philadelphia Eagles, Indianapolis Colts

0Tom Becker
Depends on the league. Manning is the poster child of consistency whereas Vick is the high risk high reward man. I'm more of a fan of Manning just because you know for sure what you are getting, but no one can argue with either guy.

Who is a more exciting player: Peyton Manning or Philip Rivers?
Asked in: Peyton Manning, Philip Rivers, Quarterbacks, Indianapolis Colts, San Diego Chargers

0Aaron Jackson
Peyton. With the possible exceptions of Vick and now Rodgers, no one is more fun to watch run an offense.

It's starting to look like Manning could maybe miss a game or two... any predictions when he will start his first game this year?
Asked in: Peyton Manning, Indianapolis Colts, Quarterbacks

1Christopher M Davis
My money is on him going Week 1. He's is too much of a competitor, first of all, to let his health get in the way of at least trying to start a game that matters and to people who play because all they want to do is win he'll be out there to start. Finishing those first few games though is another story. He starts week 1 and 2. Plays a complete game week 3. If Favre was the iron man, Peyton is like, I dunno, stretch armstrong. Second, the only way Peyton's streak dies is if the worst case scenario is career ending, and in this case, from what trainers have said his problem is, it doesn't sound like him starting week 1 would be catastrophic if he gets bumped around some. Too much on the line for him personally to let himself be benched.

How early is too early to draft a QB?
Asked in: Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Philip Rivers, Quarterbacks, Michael Vick

4Ron Hogsett
I agree, this year it seems likes QBs have been going earlier than years past. My strategy has been based on the league I'm drafting in(12man vs 10man, 4 point passer TD vs 6) and my draft position. In a 10 man with Yahoo! default, I can see QB's start going by the 2nd round. I personally like the idea of grabbing a QB early enough to snag a top 5 considering they are top "point-getters" season after season. If you are playing in a smart league, it’s plausible that the top 5 QBs could all be gone by the end of the 2nd round. Drafting a QB late would have to be determined by the quality of RB's you’ve taken in the first two picks and the quality of WR's available in your 3rd and 4th picks, and which QB may be available in the 5th and 6th rounds (typically those outside the top 10). I think waiting beyond the 4th round for a QB would be a mistake. In a 6 point passer TD league, I'd expect the top 10 QB's to be gone by the end of the 2nd round. QB's outside the top 10 have an EV that quickly drops, relative to expected point production. At the expense of a top running back, I'd prefer to see a more consistent QB in the early early rounds of the draft in this situation.So, to answer, I would say drafting first overall in a league with 4 point passer TD is too early, but not in a 6 point passer TD league.

3 too early for QB?
Asked in: Peyton Manning, Aaron Rodgers, Michael Vick, Quarterbacks

1Nik Bonaddio
In a 6 point passing TD league, I think if you can get Aaron there, it might be a great pick. Ditto with Tom Brady. The draft kit can definitely help you with this!

With the news of Peyton being doubtful, is Kerry Collins a worthwhile pickup?
Asked in: Indianapolis Colts, Peyton Manning

3Sean Weinstock
Kerry Collins is the greatest show on turf! Behind Alex Smith.

What are your thoughts on Jim Tressel in Indy (and his suspension)?
Asked in: Indianapolis Colts, Peyton Manning

0Sean Weinstock
Been thinking a lot about the hypocrisy involved in the NFL. Lots of suspensions and fines for players performing unsavory acts, but then Tressel gets picked up in Indy despite being a total fake. I don't know. Complicated. I guess the NFL is admitting that this kind of stuff happens all the time and that the bottom line is winning/fans spending money.

Who should I start, Kerry Collins or Donovan McNabb?
Asked in: Donovan McNabb, Peyton Manning, Minnesota Vikings, Indianapolis Colts

0Sean Weinstock
kerry's a solid qb. but i have a feeling that donovan's going to find his groove again in minnesota. it'll be the second coming of randall cuningham.

How long do you think Peyton is going to be out?
Asked in: Indianapolis Colts, Quarterbacks, Peyton Manning

0Daniel Okopnyi
There are two reports this week of the whole season and I haven't seen anything from the Colts camp denying it yet. Doctor's are saying there is no time table for that type of injury, it's purely regenerative. So depending on his ability to heal. Personally I would say half the season.

How many games do you think the Colts are going to win?
Asked in: Peyton Manning, Reggie Wayne, Pierre Garcon, Joseph Addai, Indianapolis Colts

0Steve Morris
I'd say 3 or 4 games looking at their schedule. That is, unless they can cull Favre out of retirement! It's desperation time in Indy...

Who has been the worst fantasy disaster so far?
Asked in: Jamaal Charles, Peyton Manning, Rashard Mendenhall, Chris Johnson

1anthony daniele
How about having drafted PM and CJ and KBritt! !!!! how am I doing?

Ask A Question About Peyton Manning

Make sure you add tags! Start with players, teams, and positions.

Ask Question
Ask Your Friends

Share With Friends

My Teams

Fire Chief

The Chief
Nik Bønaddio

Fire Chief™ refers to the user who has the most up-votes on answers for this topic. The more you share and the better your answers, the higher chance you have of being Fire Chief™!