numberFire uses the powers of quantitative analysis to be the world's most accurate predictor of fantasy football and football handicapping performance.
How will Ahmad Bradshaw do this season?
Asked in: Running Backs, New York Giants
Bradshaw will have a huge year if he has solved his fumbling issues. He continues to improve dramatically.
How will Eli Manning do this season?
Asked in: Quarterbacks, New York Giants
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Do you think Ahmad Bradshaw is overrated or underrated?
Asked in: Running Backs, New York Giants
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Do you think Eli Manning is overrated or underrated?
Asked in: Quarterbacks, New York Giants
I think Eli is def overrated. Don't get me wrong he is good but no where near Brady as he claims (and believe me I hate Brady)
Who is a better draft pick: Ray Rice or Ahmad Bradshaw?
Asked in: Ray Rice, Ahmad Bradshaw, Running Backs, Baltimore Ravens, New York Giants
Ray Rice although Bradshaw could propel himself to Rice's level this year.
Who is a better draft pick: Maurice Jones-Drew or Ahmad Bradshaw?
Asked in: Maurice Jones-Drew, Ahmad Bradshaw, Running Backs, Jacksonville Jaguars, New York Giants
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a better draft pick: Ahmad Bradshaw or Steven Jackson?
Asked in: Ahmad Bradshaw, Steven Jackson, Running Backs, New York Giants, St. Louis Rams
Bradshaw, he's on the way up whereas Jackson has lost some of his pizzazz.
Who is a better draft pick: Reggie Wayne or Hakeem Nicks?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Hakeem Nicks, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, New York Giants
Who is a better draft pick: Hakeem Nicks or Andre Johnson?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, Andre Johnson, Wide Receivers, New York Giants, Houston Texans
Andre Johnson. The reason: consistency. The upside with Nicks is definitely there though.
Who is a better draft pick: Hakeem Nicks or Steve Johnson?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, Steve Johnson, Wide Receivers, New York Giants, Buffalo Bills
Nicks. Don't know if Stevie will have the same success as last year.
Who is a better draft pick: Hakeem Nicks or Mike Williams (TB)?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, Mike Williams (TB), Wide Receivers, New York Giants, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
This is tough, but I really like Mike Williams. I think he'll produce similar to last year but on a more consistent basis as Tampa continues to improve.
Who is a better draft pick: Hakeem Nicks or Miles Austin?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, Miles Austin, Wide Receivers, New York Giants, Dallas Cowboys
Who is a better draft pick: Hakeem Nicks or Jeremy Maclin?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, Jeremy Maclin, Wide Receivers, New York Giants, Philadelphia Eagles
Nicks seems to be the man in New York. Maclin has too many issues around him right now.
Who is a better draft pick: Hakeem Nicks or DeSean Jackson?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, DeSean Jackson, Wide Receivers, New York Giants, Philadelphia Eagles
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a better draft pick: Mike Williams (TB) or Mario Manningham?
Asked in: Mike Williams (TB), Mario Manningham, Wide Receivers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, New York Giants
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a better draft pick: Miles Austin or Mario Manningham?
Asked in: Miles Austin, Mario Manningham, Wide Receivers, Dallas Cowboys, New York Giants
I'll go with Austin but looks like Manningham might slide into the slot this year which could be big especially in PPR leagues.
Who is a better draft pick: Jeremy Maclin or Mario Manningham?
Asked in: Jeremy Maclin, Mario Manningham, Wide Receivers, Philadelphia Eagles, New York Giants
Who is a better draft pick: DeSean Jackson or Mario Manningham?
Asked in: DeSean Jackson, Mario Manningham, Wide Receivers, Philadelphia Eagles, New York Giants
Who is a better draft pick: Josh Freeman or Eli Manning?
Asked in: Josh Freeman, Eli Manning, Quarterbacks, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, New York Giants
Eli by a long shot....Eli is already a super bowl MVP ...freeman has not even been to the playoffs
Who is a better draft pick: Matt Ryan or Eli Manning?
Asked in: Matt Ryan, Eli Manning, Quarterbacks, Atlanta Falcons, New York Giants
I think Matt Ryan, although fantasy-wise there's not a huge difference. Ryan is a better in-game QB though, the normal statistics just may not show it.
Who is a better draft pick: Fred Jackson or Brandon Jacobs?
Asked in: Fred Jackson, Brandon Jacobs, Running Backs, Buffalo Bills, New York Giants
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a better draft pick: Eli Manning or Matt Schaub?
Asked in: Eli Manning, Matt Schaub, Quarterbacks, New York Giants, Houston Texans
Both have plenty of weapons but I'd go Schaub as long as he stay healthy. Eli makes lots of great throws but also makes lots of bad decisions.
Who is a better draft pick: Eli Manning or Joe Flacco?
Asked in: Eli Manning, Joe Flacco, Quarterbacks, New York Giants, Baltimore Ravens
I actually like Eli a lot this year, so I think I'm going to go with Eli.
Who is a more exciting player: Maurice Jones-Drew or Ahmad Bradshaw?
Asked in: Maurice Jones-Drew, Ahmad Bradshaw, Running Backs, Jacksonville Jaguars, New York Giants
I think Ahmad is more exciting at this point even though MJD is the proven back. Bradshaw showed some great things last season.
Who is a more exciting player: Ahmad Bradshaw or Steven Jackson?
Asked in: Ahmad Bradshaw, Steven Jackson, Running Backs, New York Giants, St. Louis Rams
Bradshaw is poised for a huge year. S.Jax doesn't have so much flash anymore, but still a productive player.
Who is a more exciting player: Reggie Wayne or Hakeem Nicks?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Hakeem Nicks, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, New York Giants
Right now, Hakeem Nicks since everyone seems to have forgotten about Reggie Wayne. I think Wayne will be the bigger producer since he has the better of the two Manning brothers throwing to him.
Who is a more exciting player: Hakeem Nicks or Andre Johnson?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, Andre Johnson, Wide Receivers, New York Giants, Houston Texans
Who is a more exciting player: Hakeem Nicks or Steve Johnson?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, Steve Johnson, Wide Receivers, New York Giants, Buffalo Bills
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Hakeem Nicks or Mike Williams (TB)?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, Mike Williams (TB), Wide Receivers, New York Giants, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Who is a more exciting player: DeSean Jackson or Mario Manningham?
Asked in: DeSean Jackson, Mario Manningham, Wide Receivers, Philadelphia Eagles, New York Giants
DeSean is one of the most exciting players in the league, gotta be him.
Who is a more exciting player: Terrell Owens or Mario Manningham?
Asked in: Mario Manningham, Wide Receivers, Cincinnati Bengals, New York Giants
Who is a more exciting player: Larry Fitzgerald or Mario Manningham?
Asked in: Larry Fitzgerald, Mario Manningham, Wide Receivers, Arizona Cardinals, New York Giants
Who is a more exciting player: Mario Manningham or Santana Moss?
Asked in: Mario Manningham, Santana Moss, Wide Receivers, New York Giants, Washington Redskins
Manningham. Moss could be a lot more exciting with a better QB under center.
Who is a more exciting player: Josh Freeman or Eli Manning?
Asked in: Josh Freeman, Eli Manning, Quarterbacks, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, New York Giants
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Matt Ryan or Eli Manning?
Asked in: Matt Ryan, Eli Manning, Quarterbacks, Atlanta Falcons, New York Giants
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Eli Manning or Matt Schaub?
Asked in: Eli Manning, Matt Schaub, Quarterbacks, New York Giants, Houston Texans
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Brandon Jacobs or Jahvid Best?
Asked in: Brandon Jacobs, Jahvid Best, Running Backs, New York Giants, Detroit Lions
I laughed out loud at this. Jahvid Best is far more dynamic on the field. When I think of the two I think "how many times can you watch stock footage of a freight train running over stalled compact cars?" For me at least, the answer is Jahvid Best. The guys got crazy potential if he can stay healthy and watching him walk that line and beat guys in the open field with his box of tricks and power, knowing the next hit he takes might end his career with a concussion... pretty awesome. Tired of watching Jacobs steam roll defensive backs and throw tantrums.
Who is a more exciting player: Brandon Jacobs or LeGarrette Blount?
Asked in: Brandon Jacobs, LeGarrette Blount, Running Backs, New York Giants, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Brandon Jacobs or Thomas Jones?
Asked in: Brandon Jacobs, Thomas Jones, Running Backs, New York Giants, Kansas City Chiefs
TJ still produced last year even behind Jamaal. Jacobs fell off the wagon and lost his head...er, helmet.
Who is a more exciting player: Brandon Jacobs or Felix Jones?
Asked in: Brandon Jacobs, Felix Jones, Running Backs, New York Giants, Dallas Cowboys
Who is a more exciting player: Brandon Jacobs or Michael Bush?
Asked in: Brandon Jacobs, Michael Bush, Running Backs, New York Giants, Oakland Raiders
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who should I consider drafting first?? - 6th pick, PPR league, 10 teams.
Asked in: New York Giants
Check the draft kit. I would take top guy out of: Arian Foster, Ray Rice, Chris Johnson, Jamaal Charles, Adrian Peterson, Andre Johnson, Roddy White. Also really like Matt Forte/LeSean McCoy in PPR but you might be reaching at 6 for them.
Is Vick overpaid on his new contract? If the answer is yes, what does that say about Eli?
Asked in: Michael Vick, Eli Manning, Philadelphia Eagles, New York Giants
I think so. Last year was an outlier and he's too fragile. He's a great player, but not worth more than a Philip Rivers.
I have already entered emails twice now to get the draft kit and now even when I enter more emails It won't let me click submit. What's going on?
Asked in: New York Giants, New York Jets, Arian Foster, Adrian Peterson
Here's an idea, don't post it to the questions pertaining to players and leagues, tagging it with those players. Try the FAQ, Suggestions/Bug Fixes or contact someone on the Forums. Otherwise, I don't think the regulars here can help you friend!
Who will be better this year Victor Cruz or Earl Bennett?
Asked in: New York Giants, Chicago Bears
Earl Bennett would be my guess, although I can't say either is going to be a world beater.
Should I start Josh Freeman or Eli Manning?
Asked in: Josh Freeman, Eli Manning, Quarterbacks, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, New York Giants
I would start Josh Freeman. The matchup is good and he was doing damn well last year. Eli Manning has the curse of the interception virus. Start Freeman, especially if your league penalizes hard for interceptions.
Who should I start? Ahmad Bradshaw or Blount?
Asked in: Ahmad Bradshaw, LeGarrette Blount, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, New York Giants
I like both here, but I rather go up against Washington's defense rather than Detroit's, therefore I vote Bradshaw. Aside from the defenses they'll be seeing, I think both would put up similar numbers.
Should I start Sam Bradford at Home against Philly Def or Eli Manning on the road Vs Wash Def?
Asked in: Sam Bradford, St. Louis Rams, Quarterbacks, Eli Manning, New York Giants, Quarterbacks
Hmmmm. That's a great question. I think I'd start Eli, just because he's got more weapons. I think Bradford has the higher potential though.
WSIS- Britt (vs Ravens) or Manningham (vs Rams on MNF)?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, Kenny Britt, Mario Manningham, Tennessee Titans, New York Giants, Baltimore Ravens, St. Louis Rams
Flex: Brandon Jacobs, Jabar Gaffney, or Brandon Gibson?
Asked in: Brandon Jacobs, Jabar Gaffney, Brandon Gibson, Knowshon Moreno, Michael Crabtree, Washington Redskins, New York Giants, St. Louis Rams
I think Gaffney and Gibson are both better than Jacobs especially in PPR. Gaffney and Gibson are a coin toss in my opinion so go with your gut. I'd probably lean towards Gaffney because as you said AZ looked really bad and I'm a little worried about Bradford tweaking his finger again..
Should I trade Brandon Jacobs for Ryan Mathews?
Asked in: Ryan Mathews, Brandon Jacobs, San Diego Chargers, New York Giants, Running Backs
Yeah, I'd rather have Mathews. He gets way more touches (both carries and receptions). With Jacobs you are praying for a TD every week.
Flex RB/WR spot should be used on: Shonne Green, Kendall Hunter, Victor Cruz or Micheal Jenkins?
Asked in: Shonn Greene, Kendall Hunter, New York Giants, New York Jets, San Francisco 49ers, Minnesota Vikings
I can't agree here. I would pick up Starks for just this week. Greene had a season high of 59 yards last week!!! LT is starting to take over again this year it seems since he is more involved in the passing game! you My just want to go with Hunter if u can't pick up anyone else
V. Cruz, Denarius Moore, or Plaxico week 4?
Asked in: New York Giants, Oakland Raiders, New York Jets
Moore is the best bet. NE Secondary is Garbage. they have allowed alot of passing yards .
Week 4 Start, which 2?: Mario Manningham, Mike Williams (TB) or Eric Decker
Asked in: Mario Manningham, Mike Williams (TB), New York Giants, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
They're all the same guy, but I think Manningham has the biggest chance to score.
I feel like GAMBLING...on my 2nd WR (PPR) so WHO you like : Johnny Knox, Michael Jenkins or Victor Cruz?
Asked in: Johnny Knox, Chicago Bears, Michael Jenkins, Minnesota Vikings, New York Giants
Who do you think is the best start today Eli, Cam or Vick?
Asked in: Quarterbacks, Michael Vick, Cam Newton, Eli Manning, Carolina Panthers, Philadelphia Eagles, New York Giants
Does Victor Cruz continue to do great...or is Nicks the better consistent receiver?
Asked in: Hakeem Nicks, New York Giants
Nicks draws a lot of double coverage and the defenses prepare for him. Cruz is kind of a wildcard and not even a starter really, so he's likely to find himself in favorable matchups and have the ball go his way. With his blunders in the last two games, fumble, tip, you never know what that leads to but on net he should be pretty serious candidate to score anytime he touches the ball. I expect a few more slip screens in his direction which also opens things up for him. Nicks should be more dependable but if your team is stable and can take some spikes, Cruz can win a game for you.
Should I play Victor Cruz or Jahvid Best at the flex position?
Asked in: Jahvid Best, Detroit Lions, New York Giants
I generally go with running backs over receivers in flex spots, but I can see the concern with the Niners run defense. I still think Best over Cruz (Cruz had a really lucky week last week).
Boldin or Manningham
Asked in: Anquan Boldin, Mario Manningham, New York Giants, Baltimore Ravens
I like Boldin more. He has been getting more targets every week. but it sucks for them both that they have bad QB's
Pick 2: Antonio Brown, Mario Manningham, Torrey Smith.
Asked in: Pittsburgh Steelers, New York Giants, Baltimore Ravens, Wide Receivers
Help deciding players to start week 10. scoring plus league. make it or break it time.
Asked in: Rashard Mendenhall, Steve Smith (CAR), Anquan Boldin, Beanie Wells, Brandon Jacobs, Owen Daniels, Jake Ballard, New York Giants, New York Giants, Houston Texans, Baltimore Ravens, Carolina Panthers, Arizona Cardinals, Dallas Cowboys
Start Beanie and Mendenhall unless Bradshaw is out (if so, start Jacobs over Mendenhall). Those WR are tough. Steve Smith and Boldin are definite starts. I'd probably go with Decker in that last spot.
Help deciding players to start week 10. scoring plus league. make it or break it time.
Asked in: Rashard Mendenhall, Steve Smith (CAR), Anquan Boldin, Beanie Wells, Brandon Jacobs, Owen Daniels, Jake Ballard, New York Giants, New York Giants, Houston Texans, Baltimore Ravens, Carolina Panthers, Arizona Cardinals, Dallas Cowboys
Start Beanie and Mendenhall unless Bradshaw is out (if so, start Jacobs over Mendenhall). Those WR are tough. Steve Smith and Boldin are definite starts. I'd probably go with Decker in that last spot.
PPR- Pick 2: Larry Fitzgerald, Miles Austin, Steve Breaston, Victor Cruz
Asked in: Larry Fitzgerald, Miles Austin, Steve Breaston, Arizona Cardinals, New York Giants, Dallas Cowboys, Kansas City Chiefs, Pittsburgh Steelers
ouch man!! Cruz definitely! and then I would probably go with Fitz. I would wait til Miles can finish at least one full game this season before I play him.
Tim " JESUS in CLEATS " Tebow OR "I b`ELI`eve in MANNING" ???
Asked in: Tim Tebow, Eli Manning, Denver Broncos, New York Giants
I'm not a fan of Tebow though he has done well. he knows how to win and his Defense is amazing in keeping the score low for his comeback ability. But I can't ignore Eli's numbers this season, even in the fourth quarter. he has the best numbers in the 4th quarter out of all Qb's and he has to many weapons for Dallas to stop him. He has played himself to be in the top 5 among Qb's in my mind. Chi is the best tackling Defense out there right now. Tebow will not be able to break tackles for long runs against them like he has everyone else. but he should still get about 20 points fantasy wise. Eli is still the better option. to many weapons to pass to.
Ask A Question About New York Giants
Make sure you add tags! Start with players, teams, and positions.
Ask QuestionFire Chief
The Chief
Nik Bønaddio
Fire Chief™ refers to the user who has the most up-votes on answers for this topic. The more you share and the better your answers, the higher chance you have of being Fire Chief™!