numberFire uses the powers of quantitative analysis to be the world's most accurate predictor of fantasy football and football handicapping performance.
How will Peyton Manning do this season?
Asked in: Quarterbacks, Indianapolis Colts
It really depends on how his neck holds up. If he's healthy, he's probably a top 5 QB (although slightly overrated) but if not, watch out. Curtis Painter? Come on!
Do you think Peyton Manning is overrated or underrated?
Asked in: Quarterbacks, Indianapolis Colts
No with no neck injury... he may struggle early with timing this year but will probably get back to the old Peyton as the year goes on.
Who is a better draft pick: Aaron Rodgers or Peyton Manning?
Asked in: Aaron Rodgers, Peyton Manning, Quarterbacks, Green Bay Packers, Indianapolis Colts
Who is a better draft pick: Michael Vick or Peyton Manning?
Asked in: Michael Vick, Peyton Manning, Quarterbacks, Philadelphia Eagles, Indianapolis Colts
Depends on the league. Manning is the poster child of consistency whereas Vick is the high risk high reward man. I'm more of a fan of Manning just because you know for sure what you are getting, but no one can argue with either guy.
Who is a better draft pick: Peyton Manning or Philip Rivers?
Asked in: Peyton Manning, Philip Rivers, Quarterbacks, Indianapolis Colts, San Diego Chargers
Who is a better draft pick: Reggie Wayne or Hakeem Nicks?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Hakeem Nicks, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, New York Giants
Who is a better draft pick: Reggie Wayne or Andre Johnson?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Andre Johnson, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Houston Texans
People are forgetting about Reggie Wayne, but I'd still take Andre Johnson over him.
Who is a better draft pick: Reggie Wayne or Steve Johnson?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Steve Johnson, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Buffalo Bills
Who is a better draft pick: Reggie Wayne or Mike Williams (TB)?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Mike Williams (TB), Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Reggie Wayne is the more proven, but Colts have more mouths to feed. MWTB is on a younger team and only has 1 year behind him. Normally you want to go with the proven talent, but it all comes down to what pick you are looking at these two players at. MWTB is going on an average around round 4 and Wayne is going around round 2, so you could really have both depending on your league.
Who is a better draft pick: Reggie Wayne or Miles Austin?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Miles Austin, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Dallas Cowboys
Reggie Wayne, always a lock for 100 catches, even though his TD numbers were down last season.
Who is a better draft pick: Reggie Wayne or Jeremy Maclin?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Jeremy Maclin, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Philadelphia Eagles
Without knowing Maclin's health status, I would say Wayne. If Maclin plays, not sure on how Manning's neck will do over the season and considering Wayne's age, I would go with Maclin.
Who is a better draft pick: Reggie Wayne or DeSean Jackson?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, DeSean Jackson, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Philadelphia Eagles
Hmm, this one is a good question. I think I'd rather have Reggie Wayne because I prefer consistency, but I think DeSean probably has more upside.
Who is a more exciting player: Aaron Rodgers or Peyton Manning?
Asked in: Aaron Rodgers, Peyton Manning, Quarterbacks, Green Bay Packers, Indianapolis Colts
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Michael Vick or Peyton Manning?
Asked in: Michael Vick, Peyton Manning, Quarterbacks, Philadelphia Eagles, Indianapolis Colts
Vick is the most exciting player in the league, not even close.
Who is a more exciting player: Peyton Manning or Philip Rivers?
Asked in: Peyton Manning, Philip Rivers, Quarterbacks, Indianapolis Colts, San Diego Chargers
Peyton. With the possible exceptions of Vick and now Rodgers, no one is more fun to watch run an offense.
Who is a more exciting player: Reggie Wayne or Hakeem Nicks?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Hakeem Nicks, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, New York Giants
Right now, Hakeem Nicks since everyone seems to have forgotten about Reggie Wayne. I think Wayne will be the bigger producer since he has the better of the two Manning brothers throwing to him.
Who is a more exciting player: Reggie Wayne or Andre Johnson?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Andre Johnson, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Houston Texans
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Reggie Wayne or Steve Johnson?
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Steve Johnson, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Buffalo Bills
Who is a more exciting player: Derrick Mason or Pierre Garcon?
Asked in: Derrick Mason, Pierre Garcon, Wide Receivers, Baltimore Ravens, Indianapolis Colts
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Derrick Mason or Austin Collie?
Asked in: Derrick Mason, Austin Collie, Wide Receivers, Baltimore Ravens, Indianapolis Colts
Collie, although I believe that Mason still has some in the tank. It'll be interesting to see what he does in New York this year.
Who is a more exciting player: Brandon Marshall or Pierre Garcon?
Asked in: Brandon Marshall, Pierre Garcon, Wide Receivers, Miami Dolphins, Indianapolis Colts
Garcon is on a team with too many other exciting players, Marshall is an all-star on Miami.
Who is a more exciting player: Brandon Marshall or Austin Collie?
Asked in: Brandon Marshall, Austin Collie, Wide Receivers, Miami Dolphins, Indianapolis Colts
Austin Collie. Marshall is only exciting when he runs his mouth. He doesn't see the field anymore, anyway.
Who is a more exciting player: Deion Branch or Pierre Garcon?
Asked in: Deion Branch, Pierre Garcon, Wide Receivers, New England Patriots, Indianapolis Colts
Garcon, especially with Branch taking a back seat. Garcon is a flashy player.
Who is a more exciting player: Deion Branch or Austin Collie?
Asked in: Deion Branch, Austin Collie, Wide Receivers, New England Patriots, Indianapolis Colts
Collie barring injuries. With Ochocinco in NE, Branch's value goes way down.
Who is a more exciting player: Pierre Garcon or Santonio Holmes?
Asked in: Pierre Garcon, Santonio Holmes, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, New York Jets
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Pierre Garcon or Michael Crabtree?
Asked in: Pierre Garcon, Michael Crabtree, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, San Francisco 49ers
Garcon. He has great hands but is sometimes a little too flashy.
Who is a more exciting player: Pierre Garcon or Chad Ochocinco?
Asked in: Pierre Garcon, Chad Ochocinco, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, New England Patriots
Who is a more exciting player: Austin Collie or Davone Bess?
Asked in: Austin Collie, Davone Bess, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Miami Dolphins
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Austin Collie or Malcom Floyd?
Asked in: Austin Collie, Malcom Floyd, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, San Diego Chargers
Floyd last year, but with V.Jax returning, I have to give the nod to Collie (if he can stay healthy).
Who is a more exciting player: Austin Collie or Chad Ochocinco?
Asked in: Austin Collie, Chad Ochocinco, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, New England Patriots
Who is a more exciting player: Austin Collie or Nate Burleson?
Asked in: Austin Collie, Nate Burleson, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Detroit Lions
Collie if he's healthy. Burleson never really lived up to the hype.
Who is a more exciting player: Austin Collie or Anthony Armstrong?
Asked in: Austin Collie, Anthony Armstrong, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Washington Redskins
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who is a more exciting player: Austin Collie or Hines Ward?
Asked in: Austin Collie, Hines Ward, Wide Receivers, Indianapolis Colts, Pittsburgh Steelers
No answers yet! Jump on it and be the first.
Who will have the best year at RB Beanie Wells or Joseph Addai?
Asked in: Beanie Wells, Joseph Addai, Indianapolis Colts, Arizona Cardinals, Running Backs
If Kolb lives up to his hype instead of his 50/50, boom and bust, history then Beanie Wells could see Addai like success. But if the passing isn't there and they fall back on Beanie for way more touches than he can handle, with defenses gearing to force the pass, he'll probably falter. Again. I suppose the Colts situation is similar with Peyton's health up in the air, but Addai has proven himself. Beanie has proven himself less reliable. If I had to take a risk on a position player, I would take it elsewhere. I vote Addai for the bigger year.
It's starting to look like Manning could maybe miss a game or two... any predictions when he will start his first game this year?
Asked in: Peyton Manning, Indianapolis Colts, Quarterbacks
My money is on him going Week 1. He's is too much of a competitor, first of all, to let his health get in the way of at least trying to start a game that matters and to people who play because all they want to do is win he'll be out there to start. Finishing those first few games though is another story. He starts week 1 and 2. Plays a complete game week 3. If Favre was the iron man, Peyton is like, I dunno, stretch armstrong. Second, the only way Peyton's streak dies is if the worst case scenario is career ending, and in this case, from what trainers have said his problem is, it doesn't sound like him starting week 1 would be catastrophic if he gets bumped around some. Too much on the line for him personally to let himself be benched.
When do you think Peyton will come back from his neck injury?
Asked in: Indianapolis Colts, Quarterbacks, Peyton Manning
Who's the biggest sleeper?
Asked in: Delone Carter, Kendall Hunter, Jamie Harper, Denarius Moore, Julius Thomas, Johnny White, Buffalo Bills, Buffalo D/ST, Denver Broncos, Denver D/ST, San Francisco 49ers, San Francisco D/ST, Tennessee Titans, Tennessee D/ST, Indianapolis Colts, Indianapolis D/ST
Assuming you mean who is going to be the most productive, I would have to go with Kendall Hunter, who looks like he just moved into the number 2 rb role in SF, where there is also a contract situation going on with Gore. Delone Carter is in an Indy offense that isn't too friendly to RBs and still has Addai. Jamie Harper is splitting carries with Javon Ringer in a best case scenario. Denarius Moore is in a strange Oakland receiver corps that hasn't produced a good fantasy WR since Jerry Rice. Julius Thomas is a TE, and Johnny White is behind Spiller and Jackson.
With the news of Peyton being doubtful, is Kerry Collins a worthwhile pickup?
Asked in: Indianapolis Colts, Peyton Manning
Kerry Collins is the greatest show on turf! Behind Alex Smith.
What are your thoughts on Jim Tressel in Indy (and his suspension)?
Asked in: Indianapolis Colts, Peyton Manning
Been thinking a lot about the hypocrisy involved in the NFL. Lots of suspensions and fines for players performing unsavory acts, but then Tressel gets picked up in Indy despite being a total fake. I don't know. Complicated. I guess the NFL is admitting that this kind of stuff happens all the time and that the bottom line is winning/fans spending money.
Who should I start, Kerry Collins or Donovan McNabb?
Asked in: Donovan McNabb, Peyton Manning, Minnesota Vikings, Indianapolis Colts
kerry's a solid qb. but i have a feeling that donovan's going to find his groove again in minnesota. it'll be the second coming of randall cuningham.
How long do you think Peyton is going to be out?
Asked in: Indianapolis Colts, Quarterbacks, Peyton Manning
There are two reports this week of the whole season and I haven't seen anything from the Colts camp denying it yet. Doctor's are saying there is no time table for that type of injury, it's purely regenerative. So depending on his ability to heal. Personally I would say half the season.
Colts Wideouts with Manning out.
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Pierre Garcon, Austin Collie, Anthony Gonzalez, Dallas Clark, Indianapolis Colts
Hmmm. On your first question, I can see Collie being a decent starter but that's about it. I don't think Kerry Collins is all that bad. As far as Wayne, I don't think you'll get much value for him right now - give him a week and see how he does, you always want to trade him when his value is high, not low.
Dwayne Bowe or Reggie Wyane?
Asked in: Dwayne Bowe, Reggie Wayne, Kansas City Chiefs, Indianapolis Colts, Houston Texans, Buffalo Bills
Bowe. Although I don't think Wayne is a terrible start like some people do.
How many wins will the Colts have without Peyton?
Asked in: Indianapolis Colts, Peyton Manning, Reggie Wayne
How many games do you think the Colts are going to win?
Asked in: Peyton Manning, Reggie Wayne, Pierre Garcon, Joseph Addai, Indianapolis Colts
I'd say 3 or 4 games looking at their schedule. That is, unless they can cull Favre out of retirement! It's desperation time in Indy...
Dallas Clark or Fred Davis?
Asked in: Dallas Clark, Fred Davis, Indianapolis Colts, Pittsburgh D/ST, Washington Redskins, Dallas D/ST
Yeah, I think I'd go with Fred too. Sexy Rexy seems to love him as a target too.
Reggie Wayne or Mike Williams (TB)
Asked in: Reggie Wayne, Mike Williams (TB), Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Indianapolis Colts
That's a pretty steep request at this point. My gut tells me Indy isn't doing a lot tonight, just cuz they haven't done a lot the whole year. I'd go with Williams.
Should I start Harvin or Garcon in a PPR league?
Asked in: Minnesota Vikings, Indianapolis Colts, Wide Receivers
Harvin. Garcon drops too many balls and last week isn't likely to happen again.
Clark or Hernandez?
Asked in: Dallas Clark, Aaron Hernandez, Indianapolis Colts, New England Patriots
Clark (although don't think either of them are good options). Hernandez won't see many snaps coming off injury and if he does, it'll be mostly in a blocking set.
Who do you like in week #6: Delone Carter or Deangelo Williams?
Asked in: Delone Carter, Deangelo Williams, Running Backs, Carolina Panthers, Indianapolis Colts
For some reason, I like Deangelo Williams more only because he has rushed for 197 yards on 19 carries in the past two games. So, just due to that fact I would start him.
rb help.... injuries killed me, injuries killed me at rbright at playoff time :( ughhhhhwhich two do i start?frank gore, donald brown, ricky williams, ryan grant or maurice morris?thanks guys
Asked in: Frank Gore, Running Backs, San Francisco 49ers, Donald Brown, Indianapolis Colts, Ricky Williams, Baltimore Ravens, Ryan Grant, Green Bay Packers, Maurice Morris, Detroit Lions
Ask A Question About Indianapolis Colts
Make sure you add tags! Start with players, teams, and positions.
Ask QuestionFire Chief
The Chief
Nik Bønaddio
Fire Chief™ refers to the user who has the most up-votes on answers for this topic. The more you share and the better your answers, the higher chance you have of being Fire Chief™!