Is Vick overpaid on his new contract? If the answer is yes, what does that say about Eli?

Asked in: Michael Vick · Eli Manning · Philadelphia Eagles · New York Giants

2 answers

Keith Goldner

I think so. Last year was an outlier and he's too fragile. He's a great player, but not worth more than a Philip Rivers.

0 comments · Share · 2011-08-30 18:40:56

Eric Schmidt

On one hand, Vick dominated games last season in a way no one since Tomlinson had done. On the other, he is almost sure to miss about 24 games over those 6 years. For me the tie breaker is, can you trust a convicted felon to stay out of trouble?

1 comments · Share · 2011-08-31 22:12:22

Edit Question

Edit Question or close this panel.

Sorry! To answer this question, you must login.

Ask Your Friends

Ask Your Friends

My Teams

About This Question

Answers
2

Views
507

Shares
0

Asked By
Sean Weinstock